enquiring.
âSurely you noticed that Caroline and Iâand Blake too, though he wonât admit itâget more enjoyment out of a guest like yourself when we have him to ourselves?â
âIn the upper hall?â Gamadge smiled.
âExactly so. Blake is really in our campâCarolineâs and mine; or I should say that we are really both in hers. But his consideration for others makes him practically a neutral, and he is not and could not be a party to our conspirings.â
Gamadge said: âItâs a large house.â
âIt is, and thereâs no reason why we shouldnât all live comfortably enough in it, going our separate ways; but Blake cannot bear to feel that his sister-in-law should be left out of things and forsaken. All this must come oddly from me, since Iâm a hanger-on myself.â He paused, and looked at Gamadge.
âNo, I understand; youâre of their blood, and all the rest of it.â
âYes. As for me, I can get on with anybody and put up with anything; thatâs one of my few virtues, the virtue of a professional dependent. But itâs hard on Caroline.â
âI can see that it might be.â
âMight be? My dear Mr. Gamadge! Caroline gave up her separate life, and what might have been something of a career, to preside in her fatherâs house. For two and a half years Belle Fenway has been in the house with her afflicted son and her entourage. Wherever Belle Fenway happens to be, she will always impose her personality; she canât help it. Sheâs always had an establishment of her own until now, and she sometimes forgets that she isnât the mistress of this one. Invalided, confined to her rooms upstairs, she dominates us.
âAnd it all came about so naturally; Blake asked her to come here until she was able to take Alden to a house or an apartmentâtheyâre of course well able to afford anything; the poor fellow is a rich man. She wonât be separated from himâthatâs natural enough too, though I think itâs a great mistake on her part, both for his sake and her own. By the way, Iâm assuming that you are aware of his affliction.â
âItâs not obvious.â
âPoor Blake thinks itâs invisible, and Belle, of course, is never so happy as when she can persuade herself that Alden is a normal member of society. Well, we have them here, we have the enigmaticâMrs. Grove, we have Craddockâa young fellow who is as well equipped to deal with a patient like Alden Fenway as I amâand we have, or had, Hilda Grove. A very nice child indeed, I am quite fond of her, but a fifth outsider. Five is a good many.â
âIt is.â
âBelleâs injury is slower in healing than the doctors at first expected; some nerve was involved, I think. Alden is a perpetual source ofâweâll say awkwardness; heâs a spiritual depressant. It isnât generally known, by the way, even now, that thereâs anything wrong with him, but itâs bound to leak out. Rather a blight on a house.
âMind you, if there were no more to it than that, I should strongly advise Carolineâas I have advised her in the pastâto seek grace and say nothing; to keep things smooth and comfortable for her father. But nowâitâs a responsibility. Iâve known certain disturbing things for some time now, suspected others; Carolineâs begun to feel that somethingâs wrong in the other camp. Sheâs getting very nervous.
âIâll go back to the first incident, which I wasnât over-much perturbed about at the time; two years ago Carolineâs dog was found dead in the street.â
Gamadge had been thoughtfully smoking. Now he looked up, startled.
âNice fellow, a Dalmatian,â continued Mott Fenway. âSheâd only had him down here in New York for a month. Some ear trouble, needed long treatment at a vetâs. Well-mannered