donât move over the letters, though, and I get the feeling heâs waiting for me to say or do something. Iâm not so sure Iâm just being paranoid anymore.
âSomethingâs going to have to change, and soon,â Bartie says, his eyes on the book. âItâs been building for months, ever since you turned them.â
âI didnâtââ I say automatically, defensive even though there was no real accusation in his voice. âI just . . . I mean, I guess I changed them, but I changed them
back
. To what theyâre supposed to be. What they are.â
Bartie looks doubtful. âEither way, theyâre different now. And itâs getting worse.â
The first cause of discord,
I think,
is difference.
Bartie turns the page of the slender green book. âSomeoneâs got to do something.â
The second cause of discord: lack of a strong central leader.
What does he think Iâve been doing? Shite, all I do these days is run from one problem to the next! If itâs not a strike in one district, itâs complaints from anotherâand every problem is just a little worse than the one before it.
Bartie glares at me. Thereâs no question about it now: thereâs contempt and anger in his eyes, although his voice remains soft-spoken. âWhy arenât you stepping up? Why arenât you keeping the order? Eldest mightâve been a chutz, but at least you didnât have to worry about getting through the day when he was in charge.â
âIâm doing what I can,â I protest.
âItâs not enough!â The words bounce around the room, slamming into my ears.
Without thinking about it, I pound my fist onto the table. The noise startles Bartie; the shock of it makes me forget my anger. I shake my hand, pain tingling up my arm.
âWhat are you reading?â I growl.
âWhat?â
âWhat are you frexing reading?â
When I glance up, Bartieâs eyes meet mine. Our anger melts. Weâre friendsâeven without Harley, weâre still friends. And even if the ship hasnât exactly been a friendly place lately, we can still hold onto our past.
Bartie lifts the smaller book for me to see the title:
The Republic,
by Plato.
âI read that last year,â I say. âIt was confusing as frex. That bit about the cave made no sense at all.â
Bartie shrugs. âIâm at the part about aristocracy.â He pronounces it âa-risto-crazy.â Eldest told me it was âah-rista-crah-seeâ but he probably got it wrong too, and besides, whatâs the difference?
I know the part heâs talking about wellâit was the center of the lesson Eldest had prepared for me. It was also, essentially, the base of the entire Eldest system. âAn aristocrat is someone born to rule,â I say. âSomeone born with the innate talent to guide everyone else.â
Bartie canât be thinking what Iâm thinking: that the only reason I was born to rule was because I was plucked as an embryo from a tube full of other genetically enhanced clones whose DNA had been modified to make the ideal ruler.
âBut even Plato says that the ideal state of an aristocracy can decay,â Bartie says.
The word
decay
reminds me of the entropy Marae mentioned, how everything is constantly spinning out of control, including the ship. Including me.
âAn Eldest is like an aristocrat,â Bartie adds. Heâs searching my eyes now, the book forgotten, as if he wants me to pick up some deeper meaning to what heâs saying. I pull my mind away from the broken engine and Maraeâs lies and back to the conversation at hand.
âBut the Eldest system isnât decaying,â I say. âIt works. It is working.â
âYouâre not Eldest,â Bartie points out. âYouâre still Elder.â
I shake my head. âIn name only. I can rule without taking on the