donât know what they are, either, but just trust me. Emily was a bully. Ellie, too.â
âThings were different when I was your age. Bullying wasnât the thing it is today.â
âJesus Christ, Mom. A rose by any other name and all that bullshit. Chilean sea bass is really Patagonian toothfish, but the name doesnât change the way it tastes. You didnât call them bullies back then, but thatâs what they were. Fucking cowards who ganged up on you and made your life miserable.â
Caroline didnât know why she continued to defend Emily, but she did. Old habits, maybe. âI always thought that Emily and Ellie had more in common than me and Emily, so it made sense that they would gravitate toward each other.â
âSure,â Polly said, sounding exasperated now. âBut they didnât have to be dicks about it. You can have more than one friend. You can make new friends without cutting out your oldest friend completely.â
âA lot of the stuff that Emily and Ellie got into was stuff that I didnât even understand,â Caroline said. âThey were listening to bands like Black Flagg and Suicidal Tendencies. Echo & the Bunnymen. The Meatmen. Music was so important. Liking the right music, sure. But just knowing the music was even more important. It changed the way they dressed. The way they talked. God, I canât believe I remember all this. It must sound so patheticâ¦â
âItâs not pathetic,â Polly said, softening her voice a bit. âOf course you remember that stuff. It was high school. You remember stuff when you are younger because there are so many firsts. Lots of memorable moments. When you get old, itâs same old, same old. Less new stuff to remember. Itâs why time seems to fly the older you get. Life isnât as interesting anymore.â
âIs that really a thing?â Caroline asked.
âSeriously? Do you even read anymore?â
âIt makes sense. I remember so much from that time. Emily and Ellie would watch Saturday Night Live every week and spent all day Monday talking about the skits and the monologue. Itâs all I would ever hear on Mondays.â
âYou had Saturday Night Live back then?â
Turned out Polly didnât know everything. âYes, but I never got to watch it. Grandma wouldnât let me stay up that late. And there was no Internet back then, so it wasnât like I could catch up on YouTube the next day. Even if I wanted to listen to their music, it meant Iâd have to find the tapes and buy them. I couldnât just use Google and know everything I needed to know to sound cool. It may be hard to believeâtodayâs world is so differentâbut information cost money back then, and I had no money.â
âYou guys were living in the stone age,â Polly said.
âIt wasnât that long ago,â Caroline said. âBut the world really was different back then. I remember spending hours sitting in front of my motherâs radio with a clunky plastic cassette recorder in my hand, just waiting to record a Meatmen or Black Flagg song. And of course they never did. Emily and Ellie loved the most obscure bands. The ones that only college radio stations were playing. It sounds crazy, but I thought that if I could just find a way to listen to the same music, then I could talk to them about it. I could be cool.â
Then came the day that changed everything.
It had started off well. An A on her French test. A smile from Randy Marcotte in English class. A substitute in gym who let the class hang out on the bleachers and do homework. Caroline was feeling good when she passed through the double doors into the already crowded cafeteria. She arrived late on Fridaysâshe had to walk across campus from typing classâso many of the students were already seated and eating by the time she got there.
As Caroline approached the lunch table, she saw
Dean Wesley Smith, Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Martin A. Lee, Bruce Shlain