slides in next to me as if weâre friends. How can she have forgotten how much weâre not? Why is she talking to me about whether Zach loved her?
âDid you?â she asks.
âDid I what?â I donât want her to sit next to me. I want to eat my lunch alone, undisturbed, unobserved. Ever since Zach disappearedâno, ever since Brandon blabbedâpeople have been watching me, talking about me. But me and Sarah sitting together for lunch? Thatâs too weird. Everyone in the cafeteria is watching, leaning forward, trying to overhear.
âDid you love him?â she asks, lowering her voice.
I roll my eyes so I donât have to say out loud how stupid I think her question is. âHeâs dead, Sarah,â I say quietly. âThinking about him, talking about him all the time, thatâs not going to make him come back to life. You do know that, right?â
She flinches but her eyes donât fill with tears. âI just asked you if you loved him. Whyâs that such a hard question to answer?â
I sigh. âIt doesnât matter. Heâs dead.â
âYouâre scared of answering,â Sarah says. âThat means you loved him.â
âIf you say so. I suppose you think you loved him.â I donât want to talk about Zach with her. I donât want to talk about Zach with anyone. Saying his name hurts, thinking it . . . I realize then that neither of us has been saying his name. We say âheâ or âhimâ or âhisâ but never âZach.â
âOf course,â Sarah says.
âWe werenât together, Sarah. Brandon was lying. And Iâve been messing with you. Weâd run together sometimes. There wasnât anything else to it.â
âYou have his sweater.â
âI was cold. He loaned it to me.â I wasnât cold. My head was in his lap. He was stroking the tiny curls on my scalp. All I could smell was him. I said I liked his sweater. He took it off, gave it to me. It stank of him. Zach reek. I love that sweater.
âIâm not stupid,â Sarah says, and I donât laugh. âYou think youâre so good at hiding things but I can read you. I know you were together. You canât keep the way you think about him off your face. I know you loved him. You did, didnât you?â
I shrug. Sarah starts to cry again. Quietly, but it doesnât matter. Everyone is staring. They can see. I wish I could cry.
âWhy are you so cynical?â Itâs not an angry question. I think she really wants to know.
âTrying to be like my dad,â I tell her, which isnât even close to true. But sheâs seen my arms-dealing daddy so she probably believes heâs all tough and cynical and worldly-wise. Dad isnât cynical at all. Not really. Heâs chock-full of hope and optimism.
I suspect my cynicism comes from pretending to be what Iâm not; covering myself in lies makes me cynical. I know Iâm not trustworthy. How likely is it that the world is true if Iâm not?
But my dad lies as much as I do and heâs not cynical.
âDo you think he loved you?â Sarah asks, wiping her eyes discreetly. I wonder who she thinks sheâs fooling.
âWho? My dad?â I ask, even though I know exactly who she means. âOf course he does. Heâs my dad.â
âNo, Zach. Do you think Zach loved you?â
I have a strong urge to punch Sarah in the face.
She said his name.
Instead, I turn to my cold BLT, peeling away the damp bread, pushing the wilted lettuce aside. The bacon is burned. I have to chew hard to get it small enough to swallow.
âAs much as he loved any of his running partners, I suppose,â I say at last, hoping that I never have to speak to Sarah again. But June is so far away.
FAMILY HISTORY
The family illness isnât just acne and excessive blood. Thereâs more to it than thatâyet another reason I take