read that poem. That was how they whiled away their time together. After theyâd tired from splashing in Sugarfish Pond and had kissed themselves numb, Ben read to Willful. They started with the Paul Laurence Dunbarâthe only book Ben ownedâreading the difficult and beautiful poems worn cover to worn cover over the course of weeks, always while trifling in the groves of dogwoods as yellow-head blackbirds and laughing gulls chirped and clucked overhead.
Willful couldnât read or write. Ben wanted to teach him, begged to, but Willful always deferred with, âMaybe someday.â
When they finished the Dunbar, Willful pulled a new book out of his pocket with what seemed like sleight of hand. âFor you, Know-nothinâ. I donât know what it is, but itâs so pretty.â
It was pretty. Leather-bound. Gold gilting the pagesâ edges, the title, Poems of John Keats, spelled out in ornate lettering. They started it right away. Ben bumbled and fumbled the verses at first and Willful constantly asked, âWhat does that mean?â The language was so strange, it might as well have been foreign. They recognized individual words, but the phrases they created were a mystery. The two boys had to train themselves to submit to the language. When they did, they lost themselves in its beauty, although they never got through more than the first few pages.
It was an open secret between them that Willful had stolen the book from the store in the white part of town. That and all of the gifts he had given him: candies, sweet apples, a pocketknife with a mother-of-pearl handle. After the Keats poems, more contraband books came. So many that they no longer fit in secret compartments under fussy chickens and Ben had to invent creative ways to stash them. Meanwhile, in the grove of sweet-scented dogwoods, Ben and Willful lamented their lack of books by colored writers, but gorged themselves on what they did have.
Spinning in a whirlpool of Iâll die if donât see him soon, Ben didnât comprehend what consumed him. But when Willful got lost in the beauty of words and faraway placesâso immersed that a look of peace illuminated himâhe wasnât just the handsomest boy in Dogwood or a thief or a lazy, good-for-nothing son and brother. Willful was the love of Benâs life. The whirlpool spun and spun. Out of the dizziness he wrote his first poem:
Underneath the dogwood trees us lie,
Sweet delights get took on borrowed time.
You is sunnier than day.
I got your love, you got mine.
Their afternoons in the dogwood groves exceeded poems and pilfered gifts. Willful loved to sit against a tree, Ben kneeling in front of him.
âUndo my pants.â
Ben obeyed, was happy to obey, happy to make Willful happy. Even if Willful didnât reciprocate. At least not that way. But he would work Ben until the cream spewed down his big, dark-brown hand in white stripes.
âWhen you gone let me inside you?â Willful asked, numerous times, during the year theyâd been together. That act could complete the circle of their intimacy, he said, but it was the one desire of Willfulâs that Ben wouldnât obey. Because one day, Willful had played with him, back there, with an intrusive finger. The deeper he prodded, the worse it hurt.
More gifts: chocolates in boxes wrapped in tissue paper; a razor for shaving; a bottle of Scotch (it made them sick); a set of suspenders, which he couldnât wear without provoking suspicion. Things he couldnât possibly use: a ladyâs jewelry box; a parasol.
He loved the books, but the gold heart-shaped locket was his favorite gift.
âI know itâs for a gal,â Willful said, âbut it made me think of our favorite poem. A thing of beauty is a joy forever .â
The thievery benefited Ben, but not Willfulâs own impoverished family. Nevertheless, he anticipated each gift, even as he worried about the consequences if