all the jokes about the skeletons in Brennanâs closet.â Cory sucked in a deep breath. âAnyway, I went through all his stuff.â
âHuh!â I couldnât help itâthe gasp just burst from my lips. It sounded judgmental, even to me.
Cory hung his head in shame.
I didnât know what to say. It was a huge breach of trust, certainly not the foundation upon which to build a solid, lifelong relationship. In fact, it sounded too much like Isabelleâs crazy notion to hire a private detective. I didnât approve. But I had to admit I was curious as to what Cory found. Did that make me guilty by association?
âYou didnât break in, did you?â Ray would want to know about that; Brennanâs residence was in his territory.
âOf course not! Brennan gave me a set of house keys months ago, and the alarm codes.â
Well, that made it all better, didnât it?
I still wasnât grasping the problem. If Ray knew about all this, he might lose respect for Cory, but nothing more.
âYou found something you donât want me to tell Ray about?â
âSort of, but not exactly.â
âThen what is it?â
Cory laid his hands flat on my desk and leaned forward to whisper his confidence.
âI donât want you to tell him about the evidence I took out of there.â
Eight
The pull of unanswered questions was like quick sandâdeadly and impossible to escape.
I leaned forward and breathed my reply, âWhat evidence?â
Cory pointed at me. âWait here!â
He leapt from his chair and raced across the showroom floor, narrowly missing a collision with the spoiler on the Mazda when his dress shoes slid out from under him on the ceramic floor. The bells jingled as Cory slammed through the front door and disappeared toward the parking lot. Clearly heâd taken my question as the green light to share all. I hoped I wouldnât find myself in an awkward position with Ray or any other lawman once heâd finished.
A minute later he reappeared, out of breath, briefcase in hand, the contents of which he dumped on my desk after furtively closing and locking my office door.
I assessed the check registers and high school yearbook, wondering if they technically constituted stolen property and what the legal ramifications might be of having possession of them, seeing as they were laid out on my desk.
âCoryââ
He cut me off. âLook at these registers, Jo. Starting six months after the crash and lasting for eleven and half years, Brennan wrote a check on the first of every month to âCashâ for five thousand dollars. He stopped a year ago. I think someone was blackmailing him.â
âThatâs a huge leap. Maybe it was to pay monthly bills.â
Cory dismissed my notion with a wave of his hand. âHis monthly bills were paid by check, too, and he made cash withdrawals throughout the months that look like spending money. His business records donât reflect this money, either.â
I grabbed my calculator and did the math. $690,000. Wow! âI donât know, Cory. Who would be blackmailing him?â
âMaybe the other passenger in the car. She would know if he was drunk.â
âIâm sure the police must have spoken to her after the crash, before they decided not to charge Brennan.â
âMaybe she lied for him.â
Cory had veered into wanton speculation now. Or had he? Impossible to know without further investigation. âIâm not sure this all adds up to blackmail.â
âI think it does. I asked Brennan once why everyone jokes about skeletons in his closet. He got all embarrassed, then he said, âI guess I didnât pay off enough people.â I thought he was kidding, but now that I think back, he seemed serious.â
That would make me think blackmail, too. âWhat else did you find?â
He dropped the check register and reached for the