law-lawyerâknows a hell of a lot about law and nothing about anything else. Iâm not sure he hasnât done me a good turnâeven if it hurts. Get me headquarters.â
While the connection was being made, Benjoy wrote a memo of his own.
Summary of Evidence
Conflict: Each states he was alone at the lockhouse. Eddis makes no other relevant statement or denial. On the events of the night there is no joint statement.
Agreement: While denouncing each other as liars, Canvey and Stranack give substantially the same account of events which only one could have witnessed , viz:â
1.
Girl arrived at (say) dusk and left at (say) 2 a.m. (checked)
2.
Love making ensued (not checked)
3.
Girl herself âphoned for car (checked)
4.
Entered car unescorted (checked)
5.
Girl was young, attractive, of prosperous classes (Checked by driver who described her as âladyâ).
Curwen accepted it with the encouraging smile.
âQuite right, boy! Proves that one of âem is telling the truthâeven if itâs only the driver.â
Half an hour later, Curwen paraded the three men and made a little speech.
âYou know that you are all under suspicion. Each of you has given me an account of your movements that conflicts with the accounts of the other two. If you wish to avoid being detained in custody, you will report here every day. You will keep me informed of your movements and absences from home of more than three hours and will not change your place of residence.â
âIf that means that weâve all three got to go on living cheek-by-jowl in that lockhouse,â said Canvey, âIâd rather be in custody.â
âI support that amendment,â said Eddis.
Curwen cursed under his breath.
âHave it your own way! I suppose one of you will have to look after the lockhouse, though itâs not my business. The other two must find a new local address quickly. Which of you is going to the lockhouse?â
As a public speaker Curwen had yet to learn the unwisdom of asking a question which nobody need answer. The silence lengthened.
âSo itâs like that, is it!â he growled. Headquarters had confirmed Mr. Higstockâs ruling, leaving him without a weapon. âIf you canât make up your minds, why donât you toss for the lockhouse job?â
âOdd man out!â cried Stranack and banged a coin on the Inspectorâs table. The others did the same, then uncovered.
âTails!â called Stranack.
âTails!â called Canvey.
âHeads!â called Eddis. âIâm odd man outâagain. I wish the police were superstitious.â
âPerhaps the Inspector will be kind enough to find us some good, clean and very cheap lodgings,â said Canvey.
âI canât afford lodgings,â said Stranack. âIâll be staying at the Red Lion on tick.â
After they had gone Curwen, working at his desk, gave a routine order to Benjoy and received no answer.
âWake up, boy! Whatâs the matter?â
âSorry, sir! I was thinking about that girl. I mean, if she has already come back to Renchester to spoil the gameâand the killers are at largeââ
âThey arenât all that at large. Theyâll be tailed day and night. Give the local police a spot of exercise. Come to that, I guess the girl will be in no hurry to get her fingers burnt. Gimme that glossy you bought, will you?â
Again he gazed at the photograph of Veronica Brengast. The sort of face that makes you think thereâs a lot behind it, when there isnât. There was that lie about the car ride. That nonsense about not being able to look for her husband! Why didnât she look for the Daimler? If there were two Daimlers like that in Renchester, itâd be a lot. She might have gone to her sister, for cover, but if she did she started the journey after two ack emma.
âLovely paper they use for these things! Were there
editor Elizabeth Benedict