to leave the house to get some milk and swimming diapers. After Abbott puts his daughter to bed for her nap, he walks into the kitchen and sees on the counter the perfectly overripe bananas, the large mixing bowl, and the recipe. What happens next is that he begins to make the banana bread, despite the fact that he has never baked anything. One canât presume to know anotherâs thoughts, but Abbott feels certain that his wife did not leave the bananas, bowl, and recipe on the counter so that he might make the bread. He knows it would never occur to her that he would make the bread. Abbott is not even considering this possibilityâitâs just that when he sees these items on the counter he feels no twinge of guilt or responsibility, no subtle marital pressure, no implicit request or demand. He knowsâto the extent this knowledge is possibleâthat his wife began to make the bread, but then ran out of time or energy. He knows she is notnow at the Big Y wondering if her husband fell into the trap she set in the kitchen. He has already begun assembling ingredients when he notices that his wife has made notes on the recipe card, adjusting the amounts of ingredients to make a two-banana loaf rather than a three-banana loaf. He thinks with fondness of his wife, who keeps these adjusted recipe cards somewhere in their home. He doesnât really think; he just feels fondness. Fondness and a kind of jolt. He follows the adjusted recipe. His motivations for baking are unclear, even to himself. Heâs just baking, and at some point in the process he realizes he is enjoying himself, a realization that leads to an overawareness of baking and the enjoyment of baking, which threatens to spoil the experience but does not. He puts the loaf in the oven and waits. As the kitchen begins to smell good, he becomes eager for his wifeâs return. He is anxious to witness her surprise. He is anxious, he supposes, to be regarded as a surprising husband. Abbott is beginning to understand that he baked only because he believed his wife had absolutely no expectation that he would bake. Consequently, in making banana bread he could also make himself, at least temporarily, into a remarkable spouse. He may have thought he was helping his life partner, but he was not. Not in an authentic way. He was never baking
for her
. Now he has gone and spoiled the experience, and when she comes home he is gloomy with the certainty that he has never been and will never be genuinely
nice
, a quality he admires. He wishes he had not baked the bread. That would have been the nice thing to do. He walks out into the rain to help bring in the groceries, but not in a nice way. âWhatâs wrong with you?â she asks, to which he just shakes his head. When she enters the house and smells the bread baking, she seems legitimately confused. Itâs as ifâAbbott is just guessing hereâitâs as if she canât remember whether or not she made this bread. She canât remember making it, and yet the bread is obviously baking, so she searches her mind for other possibilities, finally arriving at her husband. âDid you make the banana bread?â she asks. âYes,â he says, unpacking groceries. âAre you serious?â she says. She opens the oven door and peeks in at the loaf, which is rising beautifully. Then, concerned, she says, âDid you follow the recipe for two bananas?â âYes,â he says. âDid you find the baking soda?â âYes,â he blurts, as if offended. She clearly cannot believe he found the baking soda. Hehimself had been stunned to find it earlier in the door of the refrigerator. âWell,â Abbottâs wife says, âthank you. That was nice.â Together they put away the groceries in silence. Eventually he says, âI thought you might be surprised.â âI
am
,â she says. âI am surprised. And Iâm grateful. I honestly canât