port, heâd met a girlâthe daughter of a man who owned a plantation near Port Aberhardâand heâd fallen in love. A few weeks later, heâd befriended the girlâs father, whoâd quickly come to look upon him as a son. The family had offered to take him in and introduce him to the life of a plantation manager. And ultimately, to groom him to marry their daughter when he turned eighteen. He looked at Scarlet, grinned, and then shrugged as if to say âWhatâs a pirate to do?â
Scarlet hated her immediately, this girl whoâd lured Ben back to land from a life on the sea. Her name was probably something like Cornelia or Adeline. She probably had smooth, corn-colored hair and a very small brain. She probably thought that pirates were grimy and covered in fleas.
âAs for who Iâm going to name captain when I go,â Ben continued, âIâve given it a lot of thought. Iâve chosen someone very brave, someone who knows the islands well and understands what the Lost Souls are all about . . .â
Maybe Cornelia-Adeline would make Ben wear a proper coat and clean his fingernails. Likely she had an irrational fear of millipedesâ
âWhat do you say, Scarlet McCray?â Ben was looking at her, and Scarlet had no idea why. All she could think to say was, âYouâll have to cut your hair, you know.â She flushed when her voice broke on the last word.
âWill you take over as captain?â Ben asked quietly, and the Lost Souls fell silent.
âWill I
what
?â She couldnât have heard him correctly. She hadnât yet turned twelve. Granted, she was one of the older ones now that all the original Lost Souls had moved on, butâ
âCaptain Scarlet. Captain Scarlet McCray. Sound all right to you?â Ben was smiling.
âMe?â Scarlet flushed again. âUm, butââ
To her surprise, the rest of the pirates cheered.
âThree great grunts for your new captain!â Ben yelled. The pirates grunted accordingly, then swarmed her with congratulations.
All except one, Scarlet remembered, as sleep now spread its heavy blanket over her hammock. One who undoubtedly thought himself more suitable for the job. One Lucas Lawrence.
CHAPTER SIX
âAll good pirates, come to order!â
Scarlet McCray certainly didnât look like your average buccaneer, Jem thought, but she sure had the voice of a seaman. Seawoman? Jem decided that Scarlet would probably prefer âseaperson.â Heâd never felt intimidated by a girl before, but he didnât fancy getting on this oneâs bad side. Come to think of it, heâd never had much contact with girls at all, being an only child sent to a boysâ school. So perhaps all girls acted like Scarlet. But he highly doubted it.
âI said come to order!â Scarlet bellowed again. âCan everyone hear me?â
âEven if we didnât have ears weâd hear you,â Smitty called back, and received a dirty look.
All twenty-three Lost Souls and Jem stood on a thin strip of coal-colored sand in Castaway Cove, a little nook on an island shaped like a question mark. The Lost Souls considered Castaway Cove their own; they could anchor the
Margaretâs Hop
behind a rocky outcropping that hid her from passing ships and the crew could stretch their sea legs on the beach.
âThe best thing about Castaway Cove,â Tim told Jem as they waded barefoot through the sand, âis that there isnât much danger of anyone finding us here. Itâs one of
those
islands.â
âOne of which islands?â Jem had asked.
Tim turned to him, looking serious. âThe kind that make even the bravest Kingâs Man and snarliest pirate turn tail and run. Some islands are like thatâjust so completely haunted that no one dares touch them. So far, the Kingâs Men have mainly stuck to the not-quite-so-haunted islands.â
Jem