you know Iâd be exactly on time?â
âAfter Halloween, I didnât think youâd want to terrify me again.â
Sheâd vowed to never tell him what had actually happened that night. Now, she had another secret, one she wanted to tell him, but didnât dare, not until she knew Lily was really alive. It didnât feel real, that remote possibility, but she would keep it in a death grip until she found out.
As her father handed her a plate stacked with nachos, melted cheese, salsa, and his famous guacamole, her mouth watered. He said casually, âHowâs Jack?â
She bit into a nacho and noticed a book on gardening laid facedown on the table. It was winter. Her da didnât have any indoor plants. She sighed and looked at her da, saw how the shadows had left his eyes and he was smiling more. âFine. So are Sylvie and Christie. How is Jane Emory?â
âSheâs the one who suggested I invite Jack for Christmas.â He switched on the TV. âWant to watch a movie? Something scary, or an action movie, seeing as you donât like romance or comedy.â
âYou know what? Letâs watch something funny.â
C HAPTER 4
It is true we shall be monsters, cut off from all the world: but on that account we shall be more attached to one another .
                â F RANKENSTEIN , M ARY S HELLEY
S ylvie and Christie had signed up for phys ed activities that complemented HallowHeartâs posh, old-fashioned, and eccentric vibe. Sylvie took archery and Christie had fencing class, which heâd convinced Finn to try, but she wasnât very good at it. Still, it beat soccer.
As theyâd walked toward McKinley Hall, with its Doric columns and the face of the sun god Apollo carved in granite over its doors, Christie had quietly asked Finn if she knew for certain if her sister was alive. Sheâd told him she wasnât sure, but she needed find out. And Jack would help her. Christie hadnât said anything else to her since. Now, in the fencing studio, he was pretending to be busy with his gear, ignoring her, and she was tempted to poke him with her foil.
When Jack arrived after class had ended, Christie scowled and began slamming his equipment onto a bench.
âFinn.â Jack leaned in the doorway. âChristopher.â
âChristopher isnât talking to me, so he wonât be engaging you in conversation either.â
âHave you ever used one of these, Jack?â Christie straightened and twirled his foil. âI mean, in your abnormally long life, you must have.â
âIâve done so.â
Christie tossed Jack a foil. Jack caught it with one hand and stepped forward. With a flick of the wrist, he neatly disarmed Christie, caught Christieâs foil, and tapped Christie three timesââTierce, quarte, septimeââ
âbefore sliding both foils into their holders. âI wonât fight you, Christopher.â
â You canât take her .â Christieâs voice startled them bothâit was in pieces. âYou canât take her, Jack, to find her sister. Finn, you donât even know if sheâs alive or where the hell she is . What if itâs a trap?â
Jack said, âDo you think I havenât thought of that?â He reached out a hand to Finn, who clasped it. âI canât change her mind.â
Finn looked at Christie. âWhat if it was one of your brothers?â
Christie grabbed his backpack. âHeâs going to get you killed,â he said, before he stalked out of the room.
When heâd gone, Finn turned to Jack. His eyes, one of which was always darker than the other, now seemed inky with secrets. âDid Moth tell you? Where Lily is?â
He said softly, âSheâs in the betwixt and between. Neither here nor there, second star to the right and straight on till morning. Down the rabbit