day for no evident reason, the result of cruel or random violence, indiscriminate disease, other Âpeopleâs carelessness. âWhy does God let them happen?â was for many Âpeople the defining question, the simplest and most persuasive argument against the existence of God. There were good answers in Scripture, but not the sorts of answers Âpeople wanted to hear. The good answers required patience, and the long, slow learning of a new language, a language of faith. There were better questions , too. Better than, âWhy does God let them happen?â But that was a question that never went away; and on nights like this, when the tragedy felt personal, Luke even found himself, against his better judgment, trying to answer it.
He surfed through the local news again, seeing that there was a short item now on the Channel 14 website: âTidewater PD Investigates Fatal Fall.â
An unidentified woman died tonight in an apparent accidental fall from the bluff at Widowâs Point in Tidewater County. The woman was discovered on the beach by a Âcouple walking their dog at around 8:30. Details are pending.
The bulletin was followed already by a Âcouple of anonymous posters: âRIP.â And: âSad story. Supoosely the ladyâd been drinking?â Which drew another reply: âSUPOOSELY? WHOSE been drinking?â
Luke glanced again at the darkness where Susan had fallen, thinking about the famous passage from James 4:14, comparing life to âa vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes.â Maybe that would be his sermon.
Realizing he hadnât checked e-Âmails for several hours, Luke called up his AOL account. Perhaps Susan Champlain had responded during the day, he thought. But she hadnât.
He logged on to his church account, checked e-Âmails and spam, for something else to do.
And there it was, in spam: an e-Âmail from SWilkins79. Sent to him at 2:47 P.M. that afternoon.
Wilkins was Susan Champlainâs maiden name.
Lukeâs heart began to race. He clicked open the e-Âmail, and read the brief message she had sent him: Pastor Bowers, Iâll call this aft. Thanx for listening. These are the pix. Please keep in STRICT confidence until we can talk. SC.
There were three photo attachments with the e-Âmail, which was probably why it had been kicked into spam.
Luke clicked on the first: side view of a large, paint-Âchipped Victorian house. The second was a mangy field of weeds; in the distance a chain-Âlink fence and a basketball hoop, beyond it some buildings.
The third he recognized right away: it was the image sheâd shown him from her phone. The empty wooden room, two men talking, a mirror, a slant of sunlight.
Moments later, the screen door squeaked, startling him. Sneakersâs toenails clicked enthusiastically onto the porch. Just behind him was Charlotte in her silk bathrobe and flip-Âflops. She hadnât turned on any lights.
âWhat are you doing?â she whispered. Her nose twitched and she made a face, detecting the bourbon. âCome to bed.â
âCanât sleep.â
Charlotte leaned down so her face was touching his. Her skin felt warm and smooth.
âThatâs the photo,â she said.
âYeah. She sent it to me at church this afternoon. I just now found it.â
âHow about that.â She straightened up, breathing in the air. Luke looked down at the line of surf again, to the darkness at Widowâs Point. âYou better send it to Hunter,â she said.
âYeah, I know.â
He looked at the clock on the bottom of the screen. âProbably too late to call her now.â
But, of course, it wasnât.
Â
Chapter Nine
A my Hunter looked more disheveled than usual Thursday morning, wearing a wrinkled blue menâs shirt, tails out, faded jeans, work boots, her dark medium-Âlength hair sticking up in back. A can of Diet Coke was on her desk, two