Anne Graham replied. âI did a full day at their house. Usually on a Wednesday. More than usual, most often on a Wednesday. Other clients I had at the time I did half days for but it was a full day at Mr and Mrs Middletonâs. Always a full day. I was as regular as I could be but sometimes I got called in by the dole people to ask why I hadnât got a job, but that wasnât very often â once every couple of months or so.â
âYou were claiming the dole while you were working?â Carmen Pharoah raised eyebrows. âBit naughty of you, wasnât it?â Her voice contained a soft note of disapproval.
âYes, but so what?â Anne Graham replied defensively. âEveryone did it. Folk still do it. You canât survive on the dole. You try surviving on it. So I worked for cash-in-hand and everybody was happy. But when the social security people asked why I hadnât found work, I said, âLook, Iâve got no bits of paper, Iâve got no qualifications. What I have got are convictions for theft and soliciting for purposes of prostitution. So what chance have I got of getting paid employment? Who will hire a thieving street girl?ââ
âHave you?â Carmen Pharoah gasped. âYou are not known to us â our criminal record check on you was negative.â
âWell, thatâs because it was just a little lie I used to tell to get them off my little old back, sweetheart.â Anne Graham smiled. âIt helped me a lot. They gave me a lot less grief that way. You see, I knew that the social security people couldnât access peopleâs criminal records to check my little story so I invented quite a track record of previous convictions which they knew I had to declare when I was sent for a job interview. So I never got offered any job at all but I was working five days a week near enough ⦠and it was all cash-in-hand. I was canny, though â Iâm a survivor. I never flashed my money around; I always looked like a starving doley, I mean, ragged clothes, the lot. But I was well-set in those days. Really nicely well-set. I used to nip out the back when I went to my jobs and I used to use my clientsâ cleaning equipment and materials. It was a very nice little number I had going for me but the old body gave out. All that cleaning didnât help ⦠arthritis, sciatica, rheumatism ⦠my body just got old and now the state pension is sufficient. I was careful not to flash the cash about, like I said, and I put it all in the bank. All that I could, anyway. I still have a bit put by. So for twenty-five, thirty years, I was earning the average wage, not paying any tax on it and getting the dole on top of it. So yes ⦠Iâve got a bit put by, enough for my vodka and my cigarettes. So I donât complain.â
âI see,â Carmen Pharoah replied dryly. âIt was quite a way out to the Middletonsâ house from the centre of York. Did you cycle or use the bus?â
âMost often, almost each time I visited I cycled, but I would use the bus in bad weather. There was a good bus service. Their house was just beyond Skelton and I took the Skipton bus,â Anne Graham explained. âSometimes I took the Thirsk bus â same route, though. There was a bus stop about ten minutesâ walk from their house. I could cope with that easily enough. I never had much to carry. In very bad weather â I mean, really heavy rain or snow â I didnât go at all. It meant I didnât get paid, but that was the deal. My job with them was still safe.â
âI understand,â Carmen Pharoah replied calmly though still with a note of disapproval. âIt is the case with all self-employed cleaners, I suppose, all self-employed persons in any capacity. No work means no pay. End of story.â
âYes, and thatâs the downside of the black economy, as I am told itâs called.â Anne Graham
Phil Jackson, Hugh Delehanty