the correspondence course that it was a good way to go when there was nobody around to beat up.â
He smiled. Again he looked at me thoughtfully for a moment, and again he made up his mind. âMelissa Alonzo,â he said, âis one of the bravest women Iâve ever known.â
He said it with a casual matter-of-factness that was more impressive, and more believable, than an intense conviction. That told me a few things. It told me that possibly he cared for Melissa beyond the boundaries of the lawyerâclient relationship. And it told me that, because he might, Iâd have to be careful with the questions I asked him. It told me, too, that Iâd have to be careful with the answers he gave. He might not consciously lie to me, but if he were involved with Melissa, or if heâd wanted to be, his attachment to her might color his perceptions. I glanced at his left hand. No wedding ring.
It could be. Even lawyers, I had heard, can make fools of themselves for love.
And so, I had heard, can private detectives.
âBrave how?â I asked him.
âShe has this ⦠she has a really remarkable inner strength. Sheâsâyouâve seen pictures of her? You know what she looks like?â
I nodded.
His eyes were brighter now and his face was animated. âWell,â he said, âhereâs this slight, slim womanâsheâs in her thirties but she looks like a teenage girlâand you think, Jesus, a strong breeze would blow her over. Sheâs very open, very unguarded, very ⦠innocent. Almost an Alice in Wonderland figure. And she gives you the feeling that she could be hurt extremely easily. And she could be. She is . Sheâs certainly sensitive, and sheâs certainly had more than her share of pain and disappointment. But beneath all the other qualities thereâs an amazing strength of character. All through the trial, with reporters badgering her, her family ignoring her, her husband lying through his teeth up on the stand, she never broke. She had some rough moments. She had some extremely rough moments. A couple of times there I thought she was gone. I thought sheâd crumble. But she always picked herself up and got on with the business at hand. Sheâs an extraordinary woman.â
I nodded. I no longer wondered whether the man had been attached to Melissa. Any lawyer learns early on to hide his feelings. And a divorce lawyer can see people at their worst, at their most wounded, their most malicious. A lot of divorce lawyers become hardened. He hadnât. Or, if he had, something about Melissa Alonzo had caused him to open his shell to her. And now to me.
âAnd she was a wonderful mother,â he said. âCaring. Supportive. Protective of Winona without trying to smother her.â
âAfter the trial,â I said, âor during it, did Melissa ever talk about running off with Winona?â
He considered his answer. Finally, expressionless once again, he said, âIâm sorry. That would have been privileged communication. I canât answer that question.â He was trying, I thought, to walk a line that wound precariously between his legal ethics, his residual wariness of me, and his desire to help find Melissa. But he must have known that by refusing to answer the question, he was permitting me to assume that Melissa had in fact mentioned the idea of running off.
I said, âCan you tell me if she ever discussed the Underground Railroad with you? A network that helps hide women and their children?â
He shook his head. âIâm sorry. I canât answer that either.â Which again, if I was reading him correctly, probably meant that Melissa had discussed the Railroad.
âWere you surprised when Melissa vanished?â
âYes,â he saidâmore at ease, apparently, now that he could answer without playing games. âCompletely surprised. We had an appointment at my office on the