information three years ago, I would not have taken his case.â
I expected Levy to be angry, but he wasnât. Alan Levy was never reversed. Levy was the guy who got the other guy reversed. Instead, he looked sad.
âAlan, we proved he could not have killed Yvonne Bennett. We proved it.â
Levy studied me for a moment, then spread his hands.
âI make up stories. Thatâs my job, Elvis. Making up stories within the defined parameters of an established structure. Thatâs what I do.â
Talking to a genius is hard work.
âI donât know what youâre talking about.â
âThe law. I start with a listânames, dates, events, whateverâinformation on a page, facts without a narrative structure. My job is to frame those facts with a narrative, you see? A story. The opposing counsel, they have exactly the same facts, and they have to make up a story, too. The facts are the same, but the stories are always different. Same facts, two different stories, and whoever tells the best story convinces the jury. I am very good with my stories, Elvis. I can take a list of facts, any facts at all, and create the most wonderful stories. I do that better than almost anyone.â
I was growing impatient. He was giving a lecture in narrative theory, and I was the retard who couldnât keep up.
âWhat does this have to do with Lionel Byrd?â
âIâm not saying I couldnât prove it again. Iâm telling you I wouldnât take the case. Chief Marx and Ms. Pinckert were very open with me this morning. I wasnât always polite, but they were patient. They convinced me.â
âThey convinced you Byrd was good for the killings.â
âYes.â
âBecause he had these pictures.â
âThey were thorough in their presentation. Tell you the truth, I was impressed.â
âIâve seen scans of the album. I know how they broke it down and what they found with the camera and the film packs. Having this album doesnât mean he killed them.â
Levy raised his eyebrows.
âIâm not the only one whoâs had a meeting.â
âAll the album means is Byrd and the person who took the pictures were somehow connected.â
âI made the same point. These people arenât stupid, Elvis. They investigated the possibility of a second killer or some sort of an association, but found nothing to support that ideaâno likely suspects were identified through his call register, nothing was found in his residence or vehicle, and no forensics belonging to anyone else was found on the album or pictures.â
âThey couldnât find Angel Tomaso, either. Theyâre right about this only if they ignore what Tomaso said in a sworn statement, and thatâs what theyâre doing. Theyâre assuming he made a mistake.â
âMaybe he did.â
âYou thought he was right at the time.â
âIf Tomaso was telling me the same thing today, I would still believe him, but I would discount his statement. A person can tell the truth as he knows it, but be mistaken in what he knows. That happens all the time.â
I expected Levy to come out swinging for having been cast in a role that potentially made him look like the villain in Marxâs Circus of Justice, but, instead, we were arguing.
âSo what youâre saying is, three years ago when we proved this guy couldnât have killed Yvonne Bennett, we were wrong.â
An embarrassed smile flickered at the corners of his mouth as if he couldnât bring himself to admit it.
âNo, we were right. We were right with the information we had at that time. Thereâs a difference.â
âDid they go over the other six victims with you?â
He nodded.
âOkay. Do you remember Lionel Byrd?â
Now he frowned, wondering where I was going.
âOf course I remember him.â
âIâve only spent a few hours with this, Alan,
Lorraine Massey, Michele Bender