became as tragic as its contours allowed.
âBut everything!â he said. âBut all! It is a catastrophe!â
âAnd you had noâwell, personal animosity against Mr. Mott?â Bill said. âNo dislike? No rivalry, say?â
Maillaux looked astonished. He shook his head with energy.
âBut we were friends,â he said. âWe were associates. Would I permit myselfâ?â
âPerhaps not,â Bill said.
âIn addition, there was no cause,â Maillaux said. âFor the girls I do not compete, you perceive? It is not that IâhoweverâI am of an age, no?â
Bill Weigand was not entirely convinced, but he did not argue. He did not think that M. Maillaux had quarreled with Tony Mott over a girl.
âRight,â Bill said. âAs long as you didnât kill him, donât worry.â
âBut,â Maillaux said, and looked very worried, âI find the body? Yes?â
Bill sighed faintly.
âEven so,â he said. âEven so, M. Maillaux. If you had no reasonâyes?â
The last was to Mullins, who had reappeared at the door.
âThereâs a girl,â Mullins said. âThe hat-check girl. She wants to tell you something. She keeps saying she has to leave andââ
âAll right,â Bill said. âLet her in, Sergeant.â Maillaux started to get up. âStay if you donât mind,â Bill said. He smiled. âSobering influence,â he said, remembering the hat-check girl. Cecily Breakwell floated in. She was a little flushed and seemed excited. She saw Maillaux and did sober.
âLieutenant!â she said. âI have to tell youââ
She was pretty, quick, consciously (Bill Weigand thought) piquant. She seemed to poise, temporarily, in front of the desk. Bill stood up, indicated a chair. She poised, temporarily, in the chair.
âItâs dreadful,â she said. âReally dreadful. To think of Mr. Mottââ
âYes,â Bill said. âYou wanted to tell meâ?â
âShe hated him,â Cecily Breakwell said. The words seemed to scamper out of her small, pretty mouth. âI have to tell you. I didnât want to but I said to myself, âCecily, you have to tell the police, you really have toâ because it isnât anything that they wouldââ
She stopped and looked at Bill Weigand with her lips slightly parted. She looked at Maillaux.
âIâm terribly afraid Iâm excited,â she said. âTerribly excited. Itâs nerving myself to it, you know. Because Peggy is so sweet, really. I keep telling myself she couldnât have meant what she wrote. About hating Mr. Mott, you know. About wanting to kill him. But thatâs what she did write, for Professor Leonardâs class in psychology. In the term paper, you know.â
âPeggy,â Bill said. âThat would be Mrs. Mott?â
âOh yes,â Cecily said. âThey were separated, you know, and she hated him. And when we had to write this paper about emotions, she wrote about how she hated him. I sit next to her, you know, and I couldnât help glancing at her paper and it was dreadful. Frightening, you know, because it sounded so much as if she meant it.â
âThis paper,â Weigand said. âA kind of an examination?â
âOh yes,â Cecily said. âFor the term grade, you know.â
âShe wrote about hating Mr. Mott? By name? I mean, she mentioned who it was she hated?â
Cecily looked for a moment as if she were thinking.
âOh I think so,â she said. âIâm almost sure. And anyway, I knew, of course. And then in the elevator she said something about it to Mr. Careyâabout what sheâd written, you knowâand then looked as if she wished she hadnât. Mr. Carey said, âFor Godâs sakeâ or something like that and was very angry at her.â
âMr.