her lonesome.â He paused and rubbed his chin. âLater I saw Skeeter and Pratt with him, and I figured they were tryinâ to convince him to vote to do her in. Turned out there was more to it.â
âHow so?â
âOstman found out they offered Williams a share of their gold if he let them have their way with her.â
âBy have their way you donât mean kill?â
Samuels swallowed, and nodded. âIt wasnât until near suppertime that we sat back down again to hash it out. And that was when it turned ugly. Williams said heâd go along with anything Skeeter and Pratt wanted to do. Ostman and me argued that no real harm had been done except for her killinâ the dog. And if word ever got out, weâd have Apaches after us for sure.â He glanced at Cuchillo Colorado. âTurns out we were right.â
âWhat did Skeeter and Pratt say to that?â
âThat the girl was too pretty to waste.â
âWaste?â Fargo said.
Samuels did more nodding. âThat was when I caught on to what they aimed to do. I told Skeeter and Pratt it was wrong. Apache or not, the girl didnât deserve it. And do you know what they did? They laughed me to scorn. Said I was too high-minded. Said I was weak. I wanted to hit them but what could I do, me to their two?â
âAnd then?â
âIt was after supper that they got to it. Ostman walked off in disgust. Williams went over to the creek and I saw him with his fingers in his ears. I couldnât stand to hear the doinâs, so I walked off, too.â
âHow long did you stay away?â
âOh, an hour or so. When I finally went back, Skeeter and Pratt were at the fire with Williams and all three were actinâ like nothinâ had happened. I looked in the tent, and I wish to God I hadnât.â
Fargo didnât ask what he saw. Not with Cuchillo Colorado there.
Cuchillo Colorado was as impassive as a statue.
âTheyâd stripped her bareââ Samuels began.
âThatâs enough,â Fargo cut in.
âNo,â Cuchillo Colorado said. âSay all of it. I want to hear.â
Samuels gulped. âTheyâd had their way with her and then they must have beat her. She was bleedinâ from the mouth and her face was half swollen and one or both of them had cut her . . .â
âCut where?â Cuchillo Colorado said.
Samuels raised a finger to his chest and touched one side and then the other. âHere and here. They cut them off. I saw them lyinâ on the ground and about puked.â
The prospector fell silent, bowed his head, and quaked at the memories.
Fargo didnât take his eyes off Cuchillo Colorado. He half-expected him to whip a knife from the folds of the robe and plunge it into the old manâs heart, but instead Cuchillo Colorado did the last thing he would have imagined.
âThank you, white-eye,â he said.
21
Samuels seemed just as surprised. âYouâre welcome,â he said uncertainly. âIâm sorry for what they done. I have a girl of my own. Her ma died about ten years ago and she lives off in Ohio and I hardly ever see her but I care for her as much as I ever did and it would sicken me to have her die like that.â
To change the subject, Fargo prompted, âThen what happened?â
âI told Skeeter and Pratt and Williams that I didnât want any more part of them. Ostman said the same. We were gettinâ the hell out of there before her kin showed up.â He uttered a short bark of mirth. âThat rattled Skeeter, the weasel. Until that moment I donât reckon he gave any thought to what the Apaches would do to him if they caught him. Suddenly he couldnât get out of there fast enough. He said as how we should stick together, how if the Apaches did come, the five of us could hold them off better than two or three of us.â
âSo you packed up and ran for