high command made plans to create a giant underground system of military prostitutionâone that would draw into its web hundreds of thousands of women across Asia. âThe Japanese Expeditionary Force in Central China issued an order to set up comfort houses during this period of time,â Yoshimi Yoshiaki, a prominent history professor at Chuo University, observes, âbecause Japan was afraid of criticism from China, the United States of America and Europe following the cases of massive rapes between battles in Shanghai and Nanking.â
The plan was straightforward. By luring, purchasing, or kidnapping between eighty thousand and two hundred thousand womenâmost of them from the Japanese colony of Korea but many also from China, Taiwan, the Philippines, and Indonesiaâthe Japanese military hoped to reduce the incidence of
random rape of local women (thereby diminishing the opportunity for international criticism), to contain sexually transmitted diseases through the use of condoms, and to reward soldiers for fighting on the battlefront for long stretches of time. Later, of course, when the world learned of this plan, the Japanese government refused to acknowledge responsibility, insisting for decades afterwards that private entrepreneurs, not the imperial government, ran the wartime military brothels. But in 1991 Yoshimi Yoshiaki unearthed from the Japanese Defense Agencyâs archives a document entitled âRegarding the Recruitment of Women for Military Brothels.â The document bore the personal stamps of leaders from the Japanese high command and contained orders for the immediate construction of âfacilities of sexual comfortâ to stop troops from raping women in regions they controlled in China.
The first official comfort house opened near Nanking in 1938. To use the word comfort in regard to either the women or the âhousesâ in which they lived is ludicrous, for it conjures up spa images of beautiful geisha girls strumming lutes, washing men, and giving them shiatsu massages. In reality, the conditions of these brothels were sordid beyond the imagination of most civilized people. Untold numbers of these women (whom the Japanese called âpublic toiletsâ) took their own lives when they learned their destiny; others died from disease or murder. Those who survived suffered a lifetime of shame and isolation, sterility, or ruined health. Because most of the victims came from cultures that idealized chastity in women, even those who survived rarely spoke after the warâmost not until very recentlyâabout their experiences for fear of facing more shame and derision. Asian Confucianismâparticularly Korean Confucianismâupheld female purity as a virtue greater than life and perpetuated the belief that any woman who could live through such a degrading experience and not commit suicide was herself an affront to society. Hence, half a century passed before a few of the comfort women found the courage to break their silence and to seek financial compensation from the Japanese government for their suffering.
THE MOTIVES BEHIND NANKING
Now we come to the most disturbing question of allâthe state of the Japanese mind in Nanking. What was inside the mind of the teenage soldier handed a rifle and bayonet that propelled him to commit such atrocities?
Many scholars have wrestled with this question and found it almost impossible to answer. Theodore Cook, who coauthored the book Japan at War: An Oral History with his wife Haruko Taya Cook, admits that the brutality of the Rape of Nanking baffles him. He finds no parallels in the history of civil war in Japan; rather, systematic destruction and mass slaughter of urban populations appear to be part of Mongol rather than Japanese history. Trying to examine the mind-set of the Japanese at Nanking, he said, was like peering into âa black hole.â
Many find it difficult to reconcile the barbarism of Nanking
Christine Zolendz, Frankie Sutton, Okaycreations