childrenâs. âChapter Four-teen ,â she said, but Gabriel wasnât listening. His hand was in his desk cubby, and Anna Grey thought she heard the irritable crackle of his lunch bag. Bethany packed him plenty of food, but the child was always hungry. All morning, heâd sneak bits of crushed Ding-Dong, a corn chip, a peanut butter crackerâthat slow hand moving from his cubby to his mouth. By lunchtime, most of it would be gone; still, he prayed before he ate, seemingly oblivious to the mimicking gestures of the kids all around him. Looking for attention, Anna Grey knew, like the second-grade boy who always fell down or the girlâthank heavens sheâd moved awayâwho kept taking off her underwear. Poor child , the other teachers said, and inevitably theyâd ask, Why isnât he in Living and Learning? Living and Learning was Martyâs pet project, a special class for special kids that met three mornings a week. But Anna Grey couldnât admit she was failing with Gabriel, especially not to Marty, especially not now. She wasnât the same green teacher whoâd encountered Sandy Shore. She planned to surprise everyone, discover a special talent in Gabrielâart or, perhaps, musicâand encourage him until he grew to trust her, blossomed like a flower. She imagined how heâd start making friends, play kickball and softball at recess, look boldly out at the worldâbut the fact was that, nearly a month into the term, Gabriel still was staring at the ground.
What made it worse was that Marty himself had approached Anna Grey about Gabriel just last week, surprising her as she sneaked a cigarette in the teachersâ lounge after the first bell hadalready rung. âI think he needs more than you can give him,â he said matter-of-factly.
âMy recommendation is to keep him mainstreamed,â Anna Grey said firmly. âYou know how the Living and Learning kids get ostracized.â
âGabriel is already ostracized,â Marty said. âTortured might be a better word. Let me help the kid, Anna.â
âIâm late,â Anna Grey said, crushing out her half-smoked cigarette.
âCan we schedule a meeting to discuss this?â Marty said. âIt would be, I mean, strictly professional.â
He blushed with the sincerity of those words, and Anna Grey blushed too, but angrily, because even as he spoke she was imagining the scrape of his beard against her cheeks, the edge of his teeth against her tongue. Strictly professionalâof course, that December afternoon had been a mistake, a weak moment after his separation, her only infidelity, ever. Until that day, affairs had been something that happened only to other people, and even now, after the fact, it was unthinkable that she had fallen into such a thing herself. She almost wished she were a Catholic so that she could confess, receive her punishment, leave her sin in the care of someone bound by Godâs law not to repeat it. Maya assured her that the Circle of Faith meetings worked the same wayâmembers took a vow of silence so that whatever was said between Faith walls was sure to stay there. âI know somethingâs on your mind, Anna,â sheâd said more than once. âYou just donât seem yourself lately.â But Anna Grey could not imagine admitting something like this to anyone, though the fact was that she longed to tell Bill, to make a clean breast of everything. Her fear wasnât that heâd be angry, or hurt, or even that heâd leave her. Her fear was that he wouldnât care one way or the other.
Sheâd first met Bill on the IU campus during the terrible fall of Sandy Shore, when it seemed to Anna Grey that her life hadchanged, that nothing was satisfying anymore. She and another teacher were there to see a football game. Bill was sitting next to them, and they all got talking during the halftime show. As the cheerleaders kicked