GO!â
âMARY, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?!â
âSTUPID, UGLY BRACE-FACE!â
âIâM SEEING SOMEONE ELSE!â
âYOUR PARENTS DONâT LIKE YOU ANYWAY!â
Mary screamed, âStop it! Please stop it! No more . . . no more! â
The walkway fell silent. I looked into the booths and saw that they were empty. I looked back to Mary. She was curled up on the ground, crying and rocking back and forth.
âOh, Mary,â I said, and kneeled down beside her. âIâm so sorry, baby, Iâm so sorry.â I reached out to touch her face, but my hand passed through her again and touched only gravel. I crumpled to the ground beside her.
M ary wiped the tears from her face and stood up. She looked at the booths, clearly surprised that they were empty.
I opened my mouth to speak to her, but the sound of whispers behind us interrupted me.
Mary and I both turned around.
In the booths behind us were more carnies. This time they all looked exactly like Mary, and instead of screaming, they were whispering.
Mary stepped forward, and I followed. As we neared one of the booths, the whispers amplified.
âMary,â one carnie said softly, âit was your fault. You shouldâve held on to Todd tighter.â
Another said, âYou shouldnât have let him kneel on the Ferris wheel. That was dumb. . . . You killed your brother, Mary. You killed him.â
Another looked at Mary compassionately and said, âYou canât help it, Mary; youâre just an ugly girl. Might as well accept itâyou are ugly.â
Another frowned. âYouâre boring, honey. Youâve never had much of a personality. . . . No one is ever going to love you.â
Another murmured, âYep, youâre going to be alone forever.â
Another Mary hissed, âTheyâre right. Youâre ugly and youâre boring and you killed your own brother and no one is ever going to love you because of it.â
Maryâs lower lip quivered, and she shook her head violently, as if this might make them all disappear. Then she put her hands over her ears and turned and ran.
I chased after her, but as she reentered the stream of people on the walkway, Henry once again took my shoulder.
âItâs just an image, son,â he said. âAnd Iâm sorry, but sheâs gone.â
I sat cross-legged on a patch of grass next to a lemonade stand, waiting for Henry. The voices of the carnies still echoed; the image of Mary crumpled on the walkway lingered in my mind.
âHere you go,â Henry said, handing me a cold lemonade.
He sat down next to me, and we watched the crowd of people walking by.
Minutes passed.
The noise of the crowd had faded, and I could hear only the scolding, taunting, blaming voices of the carnies in my mind.
Finally, Henry spoke. âDâyou know sheâs heard those voices in her head nearly every day of her life?â
âReally?â
âYes, pretty much every day. Maybe the voices didnât always say those exact words, but they still got the message across. Those voices have been playing in her head over and over, and sheâs suffered guilt and inadequacy and fear of being alone her whole life because of them.â
I shook my head. âI just didnât know. . . . Are they always that loud?â
âNot always. As you heard, sometimes itâs a scream, other times a whisper. But for Mary, those voices are always playing, like a tape loop somewhere in the back of her mind.â
âBut . . . canât she stop them?â
Henry gave me a smile that was at once kind and uncompromising. âNo more than you can.â
âWhat do you mean?â
âYou hear voices tooâvoices that scream negative comments to you, voices that whisper, âYouâre not good enough.â Have you been able to shut them off?â
âI donât know what youâre talking about.â
âReally? Do