impression?â
âThis is confidential, of course?â
âNaturally.â
âCould be only a coincidence, but it seems to fit together a little too well for that. What time was Bullardâs luncheon date with Pilcher?â
âTwelve-forty-five at Julius Steigelâs office in the Chippendale Building.â
âThen the lunch would be over by two-thirty?â
âI imagine so. What are you getting at?â
Finch turned, half twisting his body so that he faced George Caswell across the wide back seat of the limousine. âA few minutes after two-thirty Bruce Pilcher called our office and gave us a wide-open order to sell Tredway common short.â
Caswell jerked to attention. âSo thatâs where all that stock came from.â
âWe got rid of two thousand shares in about twenty minutes.â
âI know. I bought it.â
âThe hell you did! For your own account?â
âYes.â
âYou must have a lot of faith in that outfit.â
âI have a lot of faith in Avery Bullard,â Caswell said, hesitating before he went on as if he were debating the propriety of an important revelation. âIâve been building a block of Tredway for the past several years, picking it up whenever I could. Itâs not very actively traded, you know, most days not more than a few hundred shares. Thatâs why I was so surprised when I got back to the office and found that the boys had bought me two thousand shares this afternoon. Frankly, thatâs considerably more that Iâd expected to get when I told them to buy everything that turned up.â
âWhen did you place that order, Georgeâto buy everything you could get?â
Caswell turned, squinting, as if the question surprised him. âAbout noon.â
âAfter you had talked to Bullard?â
âYes.â
âThen Pilcher must have wormed something out of Bullard at lunch that you didnât find out this morning.â
âI donât see how thatâs possible.â
âPilcher is no fool. Itâs plain that he had a tip on some really bad news.â
âThere is no bad news. The companyâs in excellent shape.â
Finch shook his head. âBruce Pilcher wouldnât have gone short on that much stock if he didnât have a sure thingâif he werenât positive that there was something coming up that would really break the price.â
âBut what could it be?â
âDonât ask me. Youâre the specialist on Tredway. Iâm simply telling you what happened. Cigar?â
âNo thanks,â Caswell said, preoccupied. âIs Bruce Pilcher a regular customer of yours?â
Finch glanced away from the match flame as if he were surprised by the apparent irrelevancy of the question. âOccasionalâperhaps a half-dozen transactions a year.â
âThatâs what I thought,â George nodded grimly. âHe has a very active account with us.â
Finch got the point immediately. âYou think he switched this order to us to keep you from knowing who was selling?â
âObviously.â
âOr else,â Finch said with a taunting grin, âheâd just gotten tired of doing business with a second-string broker.â
Caswellâs smile was a weak attempt. âUnless I miss my guess, Mr. Pilcher has crawled out on a very long limb. Heâll have a hard time covering a short sale of two thousand shares. The stockâs too inactive and most of itâs in very strong hands.â
âI hope youâre right, George. Hate to see an old war horse like you being put over the jumps by an upstart like Bruce Pilcher.â
âSave your worry for your customers, Neil. Pilcherâs the boy whoâs put himself on a spot.â
âYou still have no idea of what he might have gotten out of Bullard at lunch? Heâs a clever young fox, George. You know that as well as I