For another, despite Seventeen âs chaste reputation, some of the stories that ran were as explicit as Sassy âs early sex articles. âWe actually put in a lot of stuff that people didnât give us any credit for, under the radar,â says Crichton. But there were also articles like âHow Do I Know if Iâm Doing It Right,â which was about âperforming wellâ when readers âkiss, hold hands, or express any physical form of affection,â and another on sexual dreams. There was even one onâget thisâblue balls.
But no one in the press ever mentioned Seventeen âs sex articlesâeven in 1989, when the magazine ran a quiz titled âAre You Ready for Sex?â It sounded suspiciously like Sassy âs loss-of-virginity piece, which had gotten its fair share of attention from readers, the religious right, and the competition. In fact, during Crichtonâs tenure, Seventeen increased its coverage of sex, cutting, divorceâthe darker side of teenage lifeâand its circulation increased exponentially. But while its stories increasingly portrayed the real pathologies affecting girls, the tone was always removed and journalistic, which helped the magazine retain its patina of innocence, even among high-school librarians, most of whom shelved the magazine and looked at it closely.
A new magazine with an unexpected voice, Sassy was a much more vulnerable target. The religious right wasnât about to go up against the industryâs kingpin, which had a pristine reputation among the millions of mothers who happily bought it for their daughters. â Seventeen âs dirty little secret is that itâs really hard to know whether any of the girls read it. We knew moms read it and filled out subscription cards and renewed it,â says David Abrahamson, a professor at Northwesternâs Medill School of Journalism. âIt wasnât for daughters to enjoy, but for moms to feel good about their daughters possessing.â
The companies who ran ads in the publicationâand who certainly wanted girlsâ allowances to line their coffersâkept quiet about the magazineâs sexual content as well. âMost people on the advertising side of the business thought of it as a fashion magazineâbecause thatâs where the money came from,â says Caroline Miller. âBut the reality of it is if you talk to girls and you read all the surveys, which we did a lot of, very few people bought it for those fashion stories. They bought it for the personal stuff.â Luckily for Seventeen , its reputation for covering the lighter side of female adolescence remained an effective cover.
the end of the innocence
While preparing for the June 1989 issue, the Sassy staff spent a day going through boxes and boxes of âIt Happened to Meâs, looking for submissions about incest. They decided to ring a bell every time they found another one, and that
bell rang more than any of them had expected.
The reason for this depressing exercise was that the editorial staff was trying to prove to the business side that an article on incest was imperative. Says Mike, who remembers that there was hesitation, âWe were trying to tell them that weâre constantly getting letters from girls about having been victims of all this.â But not only would an article on incest deal with the most taboo form of sex, it would also tell girls that sometimes their parents are horribly wrong. And undermining the place of parents in their daughtersâ lives was a tricky undertaking. Still, the staff prevailed, and six months after their last sex article, âReal Stories About Incestâ ran. Written by Catherine, it chronicled the tales of three girls who had been through it.
It would prove a Pyrrhic victory, though, as Sandra was asked to step down a month before the piece ran.
âI never decided to sell Sassy âI never would have,â says