Canât be certain.â The doctor pointed to the cavity where Deek Pennerâs right eye would have been. âYou can see bone shards here. Lots of them. Being frozen like this helps a little because the blood hasnât carried the fragments too far from where they started out.â
âWhat can we tell about the attacker by this?â asked Durrant.
âHe would have been strong enough to wield a heavy object. The blunt side of an axe. Maybe a sledge. Could be lots of things around this camp, Durrant.â
âWould he need to be exceptionally strong?â
âI donât think so,â replied the doctor. âOnce our boy Deek was on the ground, it would have been a matter of lifting and letting the weapon fall. Like splitting cordwood.â
Durrant breathed heavily. âNot exactly like splitting cordwood.â
âNo, not exactly.â
âNo indication that this was an axe blade ?â
âNo. The wounds were made with a blunt object. This was a crushing blow, not a cutting blow.â Armatage pointed to the rents in the flesh of the manâs face. âYou can see here the skin has been bruised where it was broken. Nothing here to suggest an axe.â
Durrant looked at the doctor. âSo just about any man in this camp could be responsible?â
âBased on the nature of these wounds, Iâd say yes.â
âAnd what have you got there?â asked Durrant, his eyes fixed on the forceps.
âWell, it looks like a fleck of metal of some kind. Rusted, so that when the weapon connected here,â the doctor pointed to the concave shape around Deek Pennerâs right temple, âit flaked off.â
âSo now all I have to do is find a sledge, pry bar, or hammer in this camp with a fleck missing from it and Iâve got my man.â
The doctor smiled at him. âAre you suggesting that will be a problem, Sergeant?â
Durrant took the lantern from its peg and held it near the cadaver. He stooped a little to examine the body more closely. âIs this consistent, Saul?â asked Durrant, pointing with his twisted right hand at the flecks of blood on Pennerâs coat.
Armatage bent and looked closely at the manâs heavy winter coat. There was a fine spray of blood around the collar and heavier spots of frozen blood on the chest and shoulders. âYou know, Durrant, itâs hard for me to say. Iâve never examined a body this badly mutilated. Iâve looked at a few poor devils killed when their horses kicked them in the face, but this is something else all together different. And frankly, Durrant, we here in the Dominion are a little behind our cousins to the south when it comes to how we examine a cadaver for this sort of evidence.
âSo Iâm only surmising when I say this, but Iâd guess that this spray of blood is consistent with the man having first been hit while standing up. If this man was upright up for the first blow, youâd expect a fair amount of blood to spray across his own shoulders, face, chest, even his arms, wouldnât you? When he was on the ground, there would be some too, as well as across the snow all around him. But my guess is that it would spray out in a different direction.â
âThe men who recovered the body would have tracked up that snow pretty good in the process,â grumbled Durrant. âNot much evidence left on the scene.â
âNo, not on the scene,â said the doctor.
Durrant looked at him. âBut the killer?â
âI believe youâll be looking for someone with blood on his coat, Durrant. Maybe on his trousers and boots too, depending on where he stood.â
âAnd from the first blow?â
âIâd say, given the pattern of blood on our boy Deek, that the killer could not have hit him without getting a fair amount of blood on his own coat.â
Durrant returned his gaze to Deek Pennerâs corpse. âI guess