you have to say to Annabelle, and things you need to decide.â
âIâm sorry,â I breathed.
âI hope we will be able to talk about this again,â she told me quietly. âBut whatever decision you make, it is yours, and I do understand.â
I left then, and quickly. Because I didnât want to think about how I saw the tears standing out in my mentorâs bright, hard eyes.
8
When I got outside, I found Grandma sitting in the driverâs seat of the Galaxie. She had her filmy scarf in both hands, but she wasnât doing anything except staring at it.
I climbed into the passenger seat. Alistair appeared between us.
âMerow?â He head butted Grandmaâs elbow. It didnât work this time either.
I tried putting my hand on her shoulder. âAre you okay, Grandma?â
âNo,â she said quietly. âNo, Anna, I donât think I am.â
âJulia shouldnât have talked to you like that.â
âBut she should have.â Grandma wound the scarf around her hands so tightly that for a minute I thought she was going to tear it in two. âThatâs the problem. She was right, about everything. I did run away. I didnât follow the first duty of a witch who has children. She
must
tell those children. She has to teach them at least enough that they wonât accidently harm themselves or the people around them.â
âBut you didnât know Iâd inherited the magic. I never told you.â
âMerow,â added Alistair.
âThank you, Anna. Thank you, Alistair.â She patted my hand distractedly. âBut Iâm afraid thatâs no excuse. I had plenty of opportunities while you were growing up to find out. I didnât take any of them and I ignored the signs I did see.â
My mouth went dry. Alistair climbed into my lap and turned in an uneasy circle. âYou . . . you saw signs?â
Grandma nodded and smoothed the scarf across her knee, only to bunch it up between her hands again. âI told myself I was imagining things. Your father was so very determinedly nonmagical, I came to believe none of you could have inherited any talent through him.â
âWhy didnât you say something?â
âBecause Julia was right about something else,â she whispered. âI am a coward.â
âYou are not! Grandma B.B., you are one of the bravest people I know!â
âNo, Iâm not. I, well, facing highway robbers is one thing, but my own family? Thatâs something else altogether. I couldnât stand up to my mother during the feud, and then, when your father . . .â She swallowed. âWhen I tried to tell him about . . . things . . . he got so angry he threatened to cut me off from you four completely if I ever brought up witchcraft where you could hear it.â
What was I going to say to that?
âIt wasnât his fault.â Grandma unwound the scarf and wound it back up again. âI waited too long, and I handled it badly. I had nothing ready to show him as proof. Heâs so hardheaded, so practical . . . And the thought of losing touch with you and your brothers and sister . . . it was too much. So, I told myself that the magic must have ended with me. Or that if any of you really were talented, I would of course see it, or he would change his mind eventually. I told myself so many things I canât remember them all.â She wiped her eyes. âBut it all came down to the same thing. I would accept any nonsense as long as it would keep me from having to confront my son with what I knew to be the truth. I ran away from it. Just like I ran away from my home rather thanconfront Mother with her own outdated attitudes toward the true craft.
âBut the worst part is knowing now that you suffered for what I did.â
My throat tightened up and tears pressed hard against the backs of my eyes. I had no