trees would grow. We could not sit beneath them.â
âWe could climb among the branches.â
âWe are too old, too heavy, they would not carry us.â
âThere must be a new beginning.â
âThere has been an old one.â
âA new one that would carry us like an island in the sea.â
âLike a grave in a churchyard.â
âThere is no beginning in graves.â
âYou do not know,â Marius said.
âWhat is memory?â Peter said.
âMemory is a graveyard.â
âOh Marius, Marius, how I hate this world!â Peter walked away from us into the darkness.
Annabelle put on her coat and we sat on the small stone parapet beneath the statue. There was the sound of water beside us, and the moon made distances solid like ice.
âThere is water here,â Annabelle said.
âWhen you go out of the garden,â Marius said, âyou remember what was in it and the death you died there. If you remember this always then the desert is beautiful. If you do not you cannot live.â
âThere should be fishes,â Annabelle said.
âIf you cannot live you will pretend that you are living. This is the imagination of dreams. But if you remember you will not be dead. This is the imagination of reality.â
âDid you love your island?â Annabelle said.
âI loved it except that I was alone,â I said.
âAnd did you mind that?â
âI should have gone mad.â
âYou go mad with people too.â
âWhy?â
âBecause you cannot touch them.â
âYou can,â I said.
âIf you remember,â Marius saidââif always there is before you this sight of yourself being born in blood, and if you say that that birth was the first death I died because of the agony . . . â
âCan you?â Annabelle said.
â . . . then you will be able to touch people for a time even if you cannot touch yourself. People can only touch each other in the face of love or tragedy.â
âAnd yourself?â
âOh, you can never touch yourself except through others. That is a later development.â
âThat is what Peter wants.â
âI can see him talking to a dustman.â
âHe will be talking of the moon.â
âHe would desire the moon without knowing what to do with it.â
âThere is the moon in this water.â
âThat is as near as anyone will ever get to it.â Annabelle put her finger into the water and the moon came to life in waves. âOne could lie in it,â she said.
âYou see, because it is a reflection.â
âCan you only touch reflections?â
âOnly those that are true to the things that they reflect.â
âAnd will they have meaning?â
âThey will have reality.â
âI donât know if that is true.â
âI donât know what weâre talking about,â Marius said.
Annabelle splashed her hand into the fountain and ripples of laughter seemed to ease across the stillness. âYou do, but youâre so crafty,â she said. âAnd what was it that stopped you going mad?â
âStopped?â Marius said.
âYes.â
âGrapefruits.â
âGrapefruits?â
âYes.â We began to laugh. âI will tell you about it. When I was a boy we used to play a game with grapefruits. My friend would go up to one of the top windows of the houseâand it was a very tall houseâand he threw grapefruits down at me. I would catch them. It was a very extraordinary feeling and it stopped me going mad.â
Annabelle and I laughed so much that we had to stand up.
âHave you ever caught a grapefruit?â he said. âA grapefruit falling from a very great height?â
âNo,â I said.
âYou should try it. It is a very extraordinary feeling. And when you miss it, you see, it hits the ground and bursts, and that is tragedy.â