people.â
âDid Alfie know how you felt?â
âHe never said so, and I tried hard to be a good wife. But a woman canât hide her feelings. I think thatâs why he spent so much time away from home. Charles was the only one who knew how unhappy I had been. I had to confide in someone. He, at least, understood both wanting to please Daddy and fearing the loss of his love and help at the same time. After all,â she smiled sideways at Enoch, âhe had been through much the same thing.â
âAnd what happened the night of the argument? What was it about?â Thatâs what he had been building up to.
âAlfie was jealous of a photograph that he found in my bag. I donât know how he came to be looking in there. Maybe he guessed that there was such a photograph. At any rate, thatâs what he found - a picture of the man I realize now is the only man I have ever loved.â
She reached into the silk-lined depths of her black dress bag and pulled out the photo. With a shy look on her pretty face, she handed it to Hale.
Hale recognized it right away. The picture was in a cellulite envelope, like those used by stamp collectors. It showed no wear and had been carefully taken care of, probably only recently added back to her purse. The image showed Sarah at Murrayâs Night Club. The man next to her, with his hand on hers, was a slightly younger Enoch Hale.
Finding the Alibi
âIf this were played upon a stage now, I could condemn it as an improbable fiction.â
â William Shakespeare, Twelfth Night , 1601
Hale remembered when the photo had been taken, one night when they were out with Tom Eliot shortly after the Hangman Murders were solved.
He could feel his neck turning red.
âYou sure had a unique way of showing your love,â
he said. âYou married another guy.â
Sarah winced. âI was worse than a fool, Enoch; I was a romantic fool. We were in Egypt. Alfie seemed every bit the intrepid amateur archeologist. The excavation season hadnât even begun yet and Alfie had never picked up a trowel in his life, but somehow that didnât matter. When he proposed under the stars in the Valley of the Kings, it seemed so romantic that I just didnât know how to say no.â
âIf youâd sent me a wire, I could have told you how.â
As soon as the words were out of his mouth, Hale wished that he could take them back. Sarah flinched as though heâd slapped her, and he hadnât intended that. He shook his head, shrugged his shoulders, and moved on.
âRollins said you told him the maid must have heard wrong. Why did you lie?â
âDonât you see, Enoch?â Her voice was pleading. âI didnât want you brought into this. I didnât realize that you would be anyway, just because of what we once were to each other.â
And could be again? Was that what she was trying to imply?
Hale stood and walked around the conference table trying to gather his thoughts. He needed to concentrate on the issue at hand. On balance, he didnât like it that she lied to Rollins. Her reason sounded good, but if she lied to Scotland Yard she could lie to a Yankee reporter who had been head over heels in love with her. And still was? Hale wasnât sure, and this was no time to try to work it out. However he felt about Sarah, she could be lying about the argument with Alfie. Maybe it was about another man and she didnât want Hale to know about him anymore than she wanted Rollins to.
âIâm so thankful you have an alibi,â Sarah added.
âYes, I was at a performance of Aida at Covent Garden. The woman I was with can attest to that.â Sarah looked hurt, as though he had betrayed her - which was ridiculous. She was the one who had married before heâd had a chance to propose. What did she care how he spent his Sunday evening? But then, she had once been an actress of a sort. If she wanted to