physical custody. She was quoted in one of the articles I read saying that, all her life, Skylar had made poor choices with the notable exception of her ex-husband, whoâd been a wonderful and loving husband and father, but Skylarâs drinking and abuse had driven him away, and since then her mother had watched Skylar devolve into a secretive, conniving, mentally unbalanced alcoholic.
Now, it was no secret my own parents and I werenât exactly on speaking terms, but even I couldnât imagine my mother getting up on the witness stand and testifying against me when the death penalty hung in the balance.
The defenseâs argument was that, since getting out of jail in 2000, Skylar had been a model citizen whoâd turned herself around in an effort to win back her life, and custody of her son. Her attorney argued that even though Skylar was receiving enough money from her ex to live on, she hadnât quit work as a medical biller, and often put in extra hours on the job after Noah went tobed. She wasnât a cold-blooded killer, heâd argued. She was a model to struggling addicts everywhere, an example of what you can achieve when you devote yourself to getting help and facing your demons head-on.
In his closing arguments heâd further stated that it was a travesty of justice to charge her with murderâthe murder of her sonâgiven how hard sheâd worked to get her life back on track. This was a son she loved. Fought for. Devoted all her efforts to. And on a hot, muggy night, heâd been taken away from her in the most heinous way when an unknown assailant had invaded her home and murdered her son in cold blood. Somehow the intruder had left behind no physical evidenceâno DNA, no hair samples, no fingerprints, and no footprints anywhere inside the house or out. Heâd been careful, her attorney had argued. Heâd been good. Practiced even. And, most important, heâd been the one to kill Noah. And he was still out there. The police hadnât been looking for him because theyâd been lazy. Theyâd set their sights on Skylar from day one, and like old dogs with a new bone, they hadnât let go. So the killer, this random, malicious psychopath, was still free while his client was being railroaded for the crime of loving her son enough to take back her life from the brink of ruin.
I frowned as I read the closing statements from Skylarâs attorney. It was hard even for me to believe a random stranger had entered the Millersâ home, killed an innocent nine-year-old boy, and left no physical evidence of himself behind.
Skylar hadnât testified, and the defense had called precious few character witnesses. Only her neighbors, her AA sponsor, and the social worker whoâd monitored her visits with Noah, and had helped her fight for physical custody of him the year before, had been willing to testify on her behalf. Furthermore, her attorney had tried to poke some holes in the prosecutionâs case, but either he didnât try veryhard or his tactics hadnât been very effective, because the jury had deliberated for all of three days and returned with a guilty verdict and a recommendation for life without parole, but the judge had apparently been swayed enough by the prosecutionâs case to ignore the juryâs recommendation, and had ordered that she be put to death.
I read all of this, pages and pages of articles, and at the end of it I sat back in my chair, closed my eyes, and pinched the bridge of my nose. I had a headache forming as the full weight of what I was up against settled onto my shoulders.
âRough day?â
I jumped and maybe let out a small shriek. âOh! Oscar, I didnât hear you come in.â
He was grinning. âObviously,â he said, taking a seat in one of the chairs across from my desk. âYou okay?â
I nodded. âYeah. Itâs just this case Iâm about to start work on. I knew I