too good, and was too tired to keep up a protest she had in any case no belief in, she said, âAll right then, pet, hop in, but donât tell your mum or weâll both be in trouble.â
In the morning she said, âLook, Kit. As far as Iâm concerned you can sleep where ever under Godâs heaven you like, but I have to do what your mum says.â
âWhy?â
âI just have to, love.â
âI think sheâs silly.â
âNo, sheâs your mum. We â thatâs you and I â have to do as she says.â
âI donât like her when she says things like that,â Kitty said.
By the time Kitty was eight years old, her open shyness had fallen away and her stand-offs with her mother were more frequent and sometimes nasty. One evening she shouted, âI donât want to live with you any more, I want to live with Nan.â
âWell, you canât, you have to do as I say, young lady.â Susannah, who loved her daughter dearly, was wounded and retorted more sharply than she intended.
âI can, so.â
âNo, you canât. While youâre a child you have to do as I say.â
âItâs not fair. I hate you,â Kitty yelled, rushing to her room and slamming the door. âI only love Nan.â
Susannah was crying when Geoff came in from his studio. She told him what Kitty had said.
âOh, Suzie, thatâs just kidâs talk. Kit adores you.â
âNo more than she adores Nan.â
âNanâs been kind to her. Weâve been glad enough when it suited us. Donât pick a fight, please.â
But next half-term Susannah arranged for her daughter to spend it with a friend.
Kitty went down the road to tell Nan. âMummy says Iâm going for a sleepover with Flora.â
âThatâs nice,â Nan said. She had made a hazelnut cake, Kittyâs favourite.
âShe says Iâm not coming here.â
âNever mind,â Nan said, comfortingly. âThereâll be other times.â When she understood that she was not going to see Kitty at all that half-term, she gave the tickets for the new Walt Disney film to the Garrod children over the road.
And somehow there were no âotherâ times. With some difficulty, Susannah managed to organise different houses that her daughter could visit after school or over half-term, where she also spent nights when it was convenient. When Nan and Kitty met in the street they still hugged but no further occasion arose for Kitty to pass a night in the field-mouse bed.
One day, Kittyâs teacher, Mrs Allen, asked if she could âhave a wordâ.
âKittyâs been a little off colour lately. Is everything all right at home?â
âI think so,â said Susannah, trying to pretend to herself that she had not been wondering about this too. âWhatâs the matter with her?â She had noticed that Kitty seemed strained and tired.
âSheâs not eating her school meals. And sheâs getting into a few fights. Maybe itâs just a bad patch. Children go through them, same as we do. I dare say it will pass.â
But a few weeks later Mrs Allen said, âMrs Giles, if you donât mind my asking, who is Nan?â
âA neighbour,â Susannah said. She didnât quite like to hear Nanâs name.
âKitty mentions her a lot. And she has written some stories. I just wondered quite what the relationship â¦â
âShe used to fetch Kitty from school,â Susannah said.
âDid Kitty ever spend the night with her?â
âShe used to,â Susannah said. She perhaps could not have explained why her tone had become defensive. âBut weâve rather gone off the arrangement.â
âYou know, I think that might be wise.â
Mrs Allen raised her pencilled eyebrows questioningly and Susannah, who had been feeling guilty about Nan, said in an effort to be fair, âI