donât think she was ever unkind to Kitty.â
Mrs Allenâs frosted pink lipstick folded into a line. âNo. Iâm sure. But that wasnât ⦠I donât want to ⦠but I wonder if there wasnât some sort of â¦â
âWhat?â Susannah asked, feeling rather frightened.
âI wouldnât say âabuseâ, because I donât say that it was anything overt, but Kitty writes a lot about their cuddles. It seems she sometimes slept with, er, Nan.â
That night Geoff said, âDonât be ridiculous. My brother and I used to get into my parentsâ bed all the time. We often slept with them if we were ill â or had nightmares.â
âGeoff, we talked about that and we agreed. It was you as much as me.â Susannah was the more indignant for surmising that with another woman her easygoing husband would have been likely to accede to other terms for his childâs sleeping arrangements.
âAll Iâm saying is that there is nothing sinister about Kittyâs sleeping in Nanâs bed. Until the Victorian period, everyone slept together: men, women and children. It was quite normal.â
He might have added that it is only humankind among the mammals who think it natural, and preferable, to sleep apart from their young.
Kitty looked anxious and then defiant when her mother explained that there was something she needed to ask.
âItâs nothing horrible, darling, I promise. Itâs just about Nan.â
Kitty had grown wary of that word âjustâ. It always seemed to bode so much more than implied. âWhat about Nan?â
âWhen you slept in her bed ââ
âI didnât.â
âKitty, it is OK. We know you did. I only want to know what happened â¦â
âNothing did.â
âDid Nan touch you?â
ââCourse she did. She cuddled me. We snuggled down together.â
âWhat did âsnugglingâ mean?â
Kitty looked at her mother in surprised scorn. âDonât you know what âsnuggling downâ is?â
Two days later Nan received a note:
Dear Mrs Lethbridge,
We are grateful for all you have done for Kitty but for various reasons we feel the time has come to end the relationship. Kitty will not be coming to stay with you again. We should be grateful if you would not go out of your way to try to see her.
Your sincerely,
Susannah and Geoff Giles
At the end of the year, the Gileses moved house. Kitty needed a larger room, Susannah explained to Mrs Garrod over the road, when she met her in Tescoâs. For some time, when Kitty had a nightmare she would comfort herself by imagining that she was safe and warm in Nanâs large, soft, talc-scented bed. She knew better than to mention this to her mother. And after a longer while, because to do so was easier, Kitty forgot all about Nan.
THE GREEN BUS FROM ST IVES
William had not planned to go to St Ives over the May bank holiday. But four nights earlier, out of the blue, his wife, Helena, had announced that she was going to Paris with her friend, Dotty Blaine, adding casually that it would be âall right about the dog and the catsâ as William would be there âto see to themâ.
Iâll be damned if I will, William had said to himself. As those who feel wronged will tend to, he searched about in his mind for something that would demonstrate his difference from his wife. He had never yet visited the Tate Gallery in St Ives and had been promising himself that pleasure for years. Helena didnât share his enthusiasm for modern art.
âIâm afraid I shall not be here,â he said, more belligerently than he felt, for the truth was he felt rather scared. âIâm going to St Ives.â
If Helena, who was used to her husbandâs mute acquiescence in her suddenly announced but often long-brooded plans, was surprised to hear of this proposal she didnât allow it