do you have that out?â she asked.
I shrugged. âNo reason. Iâm just looking through it.â
She reached over and squeezed my hand in hers. âYouâre tormenting yourself again.â
I tugged my hand free of hers.
âIâm not. I just ⦠I miss him. Thatâs all.â
âIs that really all?â
âWhat other reason would I have?â
âLast time I found you looking through that scrapbook, you said something along the lines of youâll never be able to measure up to him. Ring any bells?â
âWhatâs your point?â I asked.
âI donât think itâs healthy, you turning him into a legend,â she said. âItâs like youâre competing with a phantom who will always outrun you.â
âBecause Iâm weak,â I said. âIs that what youâre saying?â
âThat isnât what I meant and you know it,â she said angrily. âStop putting words in my mouth. Youâre the last person I think of when I hear the word weak . I mean, my goodness, Art, how many police detectives do you know whoâve had their stories broadcast on an episode of Crime Does Not Pay ?â
âThat was the Hollywood version of me,â I said. âDad wouldâve been able to see right through it.â
âOh, Art, why do you do this to yourself?â
âBecause there was nothing brave about what I did that night to Henry Grenache,â I said. âThe entire time he had that gun aimed at me, I was terrified that he was going to actually shoot me, and I wasnât ever going to see you or the children again. The only reason I came out of that ordeal in one piece was because there happened to be a tire iron within reach. That radio show made everybody think I was some kind of hero.â¦â
âBut you are a hero!â
âNo, Iâm not,â I said. âIt was just dumb luck and fast reflexes. Heroism never entered the picture at any point.â
âThere you go again! Why do you always have to tear yourself down?â she asked. âItâs a rigged contest, Art, because youâre never going to let yourself win.â
âItâs different for you, Clara,â I said. âYour father is still alive.â
âDonât hand me that âyouâll never know, because it didnât happen to youâ business,â she said. âThatâs just your way of trying to shut me up. After all, how could I possibly know how youâre feeling when my dad is alive and well, and all I have to do is pick up the telephone and ring his house?â
âI hope to God you never lose him the same way I lost mine, because nobody should ever have to experience what itâs like to not be able to say good-bye to someone whoâs that important to you, to someone you love that much,â I said. âItâs twice as upsetting to know that he died so ⦠in such a ⦠well, that he died the way he did. Knowing the last thing he ever saw was his killer, and the last thing he ever felt was getting shot.â
âSometimes I think you wish itâd been you instead of him,â said Clara. âBut youâre here, and youâre alive, and you punish yourself with this foolish notion that youâll never be half the man he was.â
âI guess thatâs my own particular demon,â I whispered.
Claraâs arms, folded over her chest, rose and fell gently with each breath. I sensed she felt defeated by this conversation and couldnât take any more arguing. So she changed the subject. âWhy donât you tell me about the two men you found tonight?â
âAw, shoot, Clara, I told you Iâd rather not.â¦â
âI wonât go to bed until you do, and I wonât let you, either. Keep it short. But donât leave out any of the important details. Go.â
I recounted the crime scene to Clara,