the pile.
âThis is probably going to be a waste of time,â she said, pulling it out.
Gretchen unrolled the sleeping bag. âOh no,â she moaned. âOh no! Oh no!â
Gretchen staggered back from the sleeping bag, covering her eyes with her hands.
Jackson rushed to her side. She felt his hand on her arm, steadying her. âWhat is it?â he cried.
Marco, Gil, and Hannah hurried over, surrounding her. âWhatâs wrong?â Marco asked. âWhat did you find?â
Gretchen pointed to the floor.
There, in the middle of Patrickâs sleeping bag, was the missing bread knife.
Its blade covered with dark stains.
Chapter
26
âT he knife used to kill Cindy,â Gretchen murmured.
They all stood staring down at the sleeping bag.
At the knife.
Gretchenâs gaze fixed on the razor-sharp edge of the blade.
She shivered and tore her eyes away. The thought of the knife slashing into Cindy made her feel sick.
She hugged her arms around her stomach. And forced herself not to look at it again.
âI canât believe it,â she heard Hannah moan. âI canât believe that Patrickâ¦â
Gretchen suddenly felt light-headed. She staggered to the couch and sat down. She dropped her head down to her knees and swallowed deep breaths.
She heard someone walk toward her.
âAre you okay?â Jackson asked softly.
Gretchen pushed her hair out of her face. âIâm okay,â she answered. âI guess.â
âThis is all the proof we need,â Marco said. âLetâs see Patrick try to deny this!â
Marco led the way back to the kitchen.
âI canât go back in there,â Hannah whispered. She clutched Gretchenâs arm. âStay out here with me. Please?â
âI want to hear what Patrick says when he sees the knife,â Gretchen told her.
She put her arms around Hannah and gave her a hug. âIâll come back in a minute, okay?â
âOkay,â Hannah nodded. She twisted the bottom of her sweater in her hands. âIâll wait out here, by the door. Iâll be okay.â
Gretchen turned from Hannah and stepped into the kitchen.
Marco, Jackson, and Gil stood in a grim circle around Patrick.
âI knew you wouldnât find anything,â Patrick said angrily. âNow untie me!â
âYouâre wrong, Patrick,â Gretchen said. âWe did find things. Two things.â
All the blood drained from Patrickâs face. His mouth fell open, and he stared at Gretchen as if he hadnât heard her correctly. âExcuse me?â
Gretchen stared hard at Patrick.
Either heâs telling the truth and didnât murderCindy. Or heâs giving the performance of his life, she thought.
âWe found two things,â Gretchen repeated. âWe found a note in your backpack. From Cindy. She said she was going to tell her parents about the secret the two of you shared. She said she couldnât keep it anymore.â
âI donât know what youâre talking about,â Patrick said through gritted teeth. âCindy and I didnât share any secret. The note is a fake. It has to be a total fake. I never got any note from Cindy.â
They all stared hard at Patrick, studying his face.
Patrick sighed. âWhat else did you find?â
Gretchen took a deep breath. âThe missing bread knife⦠smeared with blood⦠in your sleeping bag.â
âYou murdered her!â Gil cried suddenly.
âI didnât! I didnât!â Patrick screamed.
âBut Patrick,â Gretchen cut in. âHow do you explain the knife in your sleeping bag?â Gretchen asked.
âI donât know. I really donât. I didnât put it there,â Patrick insisted.
âBut it was there,â Gretchen stated. âAnd itâs smeared with blood.â
âI didnât murder Cindy!â Patrick cried. âWhy wonât anyone listen