things like that about her. I used to love hearing him, especially when he said it in front of my friends.â Grateful that theyâd stumbled onto something neutral that they could talk about, Karla added, âThey thought he was the most romantic man alive, straight out of the movies. I told him how they felt one day, even admitted I was proud that my friends thought he and Mom were special, and that I hoped when I grew up someone would love me the way he loved Mom.â Sheâd never told anyone about that conversation, saving it the way she had the four-leaf clover sheâd found at the cemetery on her motherâs grave, giving the memory and clover special power without knowing what the power was. How ironic that when sheâd finally told someone, it was Anna.
âAnd how did he answer you?â
What heâd said was so touching, so special, as sheâd grown older sheâd developed doubts about the accuracy of her memory. âHe said I was destined to have one of the great loves of all time . . . poets would be unable to find the words to describe this love . . . that it would come to me so gently I wouldnât recognize it at first.â She glanced at Anna and met her gaze. âBeing the father of three daughters, it was almost a given that heâd develop a gift for telling fairy tales.â
âThere are so many things about your father I donât know. I was content that he made Marie happy and never thought to ask anything else. I missed so much of all of your lives.â
âWhy did you let it happen?â For once, she wasnât being judgmental, just curious as to how a mother could remove herself so completely from her own daughterâs life. As far as Karla knew, her mother and grandmother loved each other, they just werenât particularly close.
âI didnât want your father to think I was interfering in their marriage. I had such a terrible time with Frankâs mother that I swore I would never do anything like that to my own daughter and her husband. But I let it go too far. I thought I was giving her freedom, and now Iâm afraid she actually saw it as disinterest. She must have thought I simply didnât care.â
Again she reached up to loosen the shoulder harness. âThen you met Jim and I was so sure he was the wrong man for you that I rode that pendulum all the way to the other side. Frankâs mother wouldnât have dreamed of doing what I did to you. I had no business telling you not to marry Jim, and Iâve regretted that I didnât go to the wedding every day since.â
âAnd you still feel that way? Even knowing you were right about Jim?â Karla was testing. Anna wasnât the kind of woman who backed off easily or without laying groundwork for the retreat. Somewhere in the fractured apology was an âI told you so.â
âYes,â Anna said without elaboration and then laughed. âDid I pass?â
Karla laughed, too. How could they know each other so well and be such strangers? âMom said you never came to see us because you lived so far away. I told her I thought it was because you didnât like us. It must have hurt her feelings. She didnât talk to me about you for a long time afterward.â
Anna didnât say anything.
âItâs so strange . . .â Karla went on. âI can reconstruct the entire conversation in my mind, everything except her answer.â Again she looked over to Anna. âI know now why you never came to see us, but why didnât we visit you?â
âYou did. A couple of times before Heather was born and then once after. You probably donât remember because you were so little. Then Frank died, and your father was transferred so often you barely had time to unpack before you were packing up to move again. Marie and I were always making grand plans to get together, but then something would come up and