unSpun

Free unSpun by Brooks Jackson

Book: unSpun by Brooks Jackson Read Free Book Online
Authors: Brooks Jackson
Tags: Fiction
“adwatch” stories are usually careful to avoid the eye-candy effect. That’s thanks in part to Annenberg’s research. Annenberg advised reporters to use special graphic techniques, showing the offending ad “boxed” in a cartoonlike TV set so that viewers don’t confuse the ad’s message with the reporter’s message, and imposing graphics over the ad to reinforce their points of criticism. But deceivers have learned a trick or two also, as we see in those pharmaceutical ads that use feel-good pictures to soften the unpleasant truth about the potential side effects of their products. Also, politicians have taken to slapping their slogans on banners and backdrops where TV cameras necessarily show them, so the speaker’s message gets across visually even if the news soundtrack doesn’t contain a single word he or she spoke.
    An example of that is President Bush’s appearance on November 30, 2005, at the U.S. Naval Academy. His message of the day—that he had a “plan for victory” in Iraq—was reinforced with banners above and below the podium. We can make fun of Bush for appearing in front of a banner reading “Mission Accomplished” two and a half years earlier, on May 1, 2003, aboard the aircraft carrier U.S.S.
Abraham Lincoln.
That bit of eye candy was, to say the least, premature. But, regardless of what the reporters were saying about them, each of Bush’s messages was punched through by visuals that were powerful, whether or not they were valid.

    A message conveyed by “eye candy.” AP Images.
    Visuals also can be used to reinforce a false message that the deceiver can’t state outright. In 2005 the abortion rights group NARAL Pro-Choice America ran a TV ad showing a bombed-out abortion clinic and a disfigured victim, while the voice-over said that Supreme Court nominee John Roberts “filed court briefs supporting violent fringe groups and a convicted clinic bomber,” and adding: “America can’t afford a justice whose ideology leads him to excuse violence.” Roberts had in fact condemned clinic bombers and violence, but those powerful pictures transmitted the emotional message that Roberts had endorsed the mayhem being shown, even though the narrator stopped just short of saying that explicitly. FactCheck.org called that ad false and NARAL quickly pulled it off the air. Even the group’s allies criticized it.
    When you see dramatic images, listen to the “fine print.” Ask yourself, “What are my
ears
telling me about this picture?” A picture can indeed be worth a thousand words—but those words aren’t necessarily true.
    TRICK #5:
The “Average” Bear
    S OMETIMES THE “AVERAGE” BEARS WATCHING . P RESIDENT B USH sold his tax cuts to the public by claiming the “average tax cut” would be $1,586, but most of us were never going to see anywhere near that much. Half of Americans got $470 or less, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. Bush wasn’t lying, just using a common mathematical trick. When most people hear the word “average” they think “typical.” But the average isn’t always typical, especially when it comes to the federal income tax: very wealthy people pay a very large share of the taxes and stand to get a very large share of benefits when those taxes are cut.
    To see the “average bear” trick clearly, consider this simplified example. Imagine a small town of a thousand persons, including one superrich resident whom we’ll call Gil Bates. Everybody in town is getting a tax cut this year: $10 for everybody but Mr. Bates, who is getting a whopping cut of $90,010. What’s the average? Divide the sum of all the tax cuts ($100,000) by the total number of residents (1,000) and the
average
works out to $100 per resident. But that’s not the
typical
cut. In our example, the average tax cut was ten

Similar Books

Montana Homecoming

Jillian Hart

Cold Fire

Dean Koontz

The Wombles to the Rescue

Elisabeth Beresford

Love's Haven

Catherine Palmer

Dream Boy

Mary Crockett, Madelyn Rosenberg

Grub

Elise Blackwell

Waiting for Godot

Samuel Beckett

Missing Child

Patricia MacDonald

Hostage Taker

Stefanie Pintoff