youâre lost in the wilderness, right? Did they ever say anything about caves? It didnât matterâthe principle was the same. If the three of them kept going farther, that might only make it worse.
âI have an idea,â Ashley announced. âThe trail splits into three and there are three of us. I think each one of us should take a trail, since one of them has to be right. Whoever gets out to the main trail first could find the rangers and tell them where we are, and thenââ
âNo!â Jack said emphatically. âWeâre not splitting up.â
He watched Ashley stiffen. âJust listen to me!â
âNo!â
âWhy not?â
âI th-th-think we should do what J-J-Jack s-says,â Sam broke in.
âOh, big surprise there,â Ashley snapped. âYou always do everything he says. What is it, a guy thing? Why canât you ever listen to me?â
Sam looked at her, wide eyed.
âSince you believe everything Jack says, maybe you should have asked him about running off the way you did. He would have told you not to do it. Then maybe we wouldnât be in this mess.â
âHey, donât be going after Sam,â Jack warned her. âThatâs not going to help anything. Besides, Ashley, youâre the one who said you knew which trail to take. Youâve made mistakes, too. Youâre the one who was so sure that you knew the way outââ
âSo now itâs my fault?â Ashley exclaimed, her eyes blazing in the half-light. âYouâre blaming me? Youâre the one who wanted to find Sam without the rangersâ knowingââ
âThatâs because I didnât want himâany of usâto get in trouble.â
âWell, weâre all in trouble now.â
âQuit being such a drama queen. OK, so maybe weâre lost now, but the rangers are going to find us. Weâll get in trouble for making them put together a search, but weâll be all right.â
âWhat if theyâre not looking?â
The question caught Jack by surprise. It took a moment for the idea to register.
âWhat if no one has figured out that weâre gone?â Ashley said, snapping her braids behind her back. âHave you even thought of that? I have. Consuelaâs the only one in Left Hand Tunnel who knew for sure we were taking the cave tour, and she passed out. Maybe sheâs still unconscious. An unconscious person canât talk. An unconscious person canât ask about us, or tell about us, or anything!â
Jack began to feel sick. âSo whatâs your point?â
âMy point is we canât wait. We each need to take a trail and try to find the main path and get help. Weâve got to get out of here!â
Sam put his hands over his ears. Shutting his eyes, he began to rock back and forth.
âStop it, Ashley. Youâre scaring Sam!â
âIâm scared.â
Jack could tell she was. Sometimes, when she was truly frightened, his sister would grab her sides and hold herself tight, as if she could almost turn herself inside out. She was doing that now, clutching her sides so that Jack could see the jut of her knuckles gleaming white in the candlelight. The worst thing any of them could do now was to lose control. The second worst thing would be to turn on each other.
âLook, I know you think we should each take a tunnel, but it wonât work. We canât split up.â
âWhy?â
âBecause we only have one lantern. You canât walk without light. Someone could fall into one of those holes. We canât risk it.â
Ashley was silent for a moment. She seemed to sag a little, her head falling forward as if it were suddenly too heavy for her neck. âThen what do you think we should do?â Her words were directed at the cave floor.
âWe need to stop moving and wait for them to come to us. Theyâll find us, Ashley. I
The Seven-Per-Cent Solution (pdf)