fine.â The truth was she liked him a lot. If it wasnât for the persistent nightmares, she would consider herself the luckiest girl alive that such a man asked her to marry him.
âWhen Bobby Watkins and Henry Hill got into a fight, my teacher made them stay after school until they got to know each other better. Now theyâre the bestest friends.â
She smiled at his meaning. She didnât want to promise anything, but neither did she want to worry him. âPerhaps once your uncle and I get to know each other better, weâll be bestest friends too.â
Garrett arrived and his presence seemed to fill every nook and cranny. He lifted the lid off the pot on the stove and sniffed. âThatâs not possum, is it?â he teased.
âItâs beef stew,â she said. âBut I can fix possum if you like.â
He replaced the lid. âStewâs fine,â he said, winking at Eddie.
After they ate, Eddie was excused from the table to go and feed his paâs horse. She and Garrett lingered over coffee. While reaching for the sugar, he knocked over the salt.
She held her breath and clenched her hands together. Garrett had made it clear that he didnât believe in luck and she didnât want to do anything to earn his disfavor. Not while things were so fragile between them. And yet the urge was so strong.
He set the saltshaker upright. She tried to ignore the white grains that dotted the table. It would have been easier to ignore a herd of cattle moving through the room.
She chewed on a fingernail. She imagined the white grains of salt dancing across the table, mocking her. She thought of the nightmares that plagued her and she felt sick to her stomach.
âIâve been thinking,â she began.
He raised a dark eyebrow. âAnd?â
She tried to recall the speech sheâd rehearsed, but none of it came to mind. âMaybe . . . it would be best if I returned home.â
He set his cup down. âItâs only been two weeks,â he said. âYou promised youâd take at least a month to think about it.â
âYes, well, I have thought about it. Iâve also prayed about it but . . .â Much to her dismay, tears welled in her eyes. For more than six years sheâd grieved for Charles. She didnât know how to grieve for Daniel. What little she thought she knew about him turned out to be lies from Mr. Hitchcockâs pen. That explained some of the tears but not all.
He handed her a clean handkerchief and she dabbed her cheeks. âI donât think God means for me to get married.â There, she said it.
He reared back in his chair, his face suffused with astonishment. âDid you come to this conclusion because of what happened to Dan?â
âAnd Charles.â She still didnât want to tell him about her nightmares.
He blew out his breath and scratched his temple. âI donât think God has anything to do with your losses,â he said. âBad things happen andââ
Before he could complete his sentence, Eddie ran into the house, shouting, âFire, fire!â
âOh no!â She jumped up from her chair.
The sheriff was on his feet and out the door in a flash. Mary-Jo started after him, then stopped. She grabbed the salt shaker and shook it over her left shoulder before bounding out the door.
â¢â¢â¢
Dark, thick smoke poured out of the barn. Garrett pulled a bucket of water from the well and dashed inside. Mary-Jo grabbed a second bucket and followed, water sloshing over the sides.
The air was hazy with smoke, but by the time she entered the barn, the fire appeared to be out. She set the bucket down.
âWhat is that awful smell?â She wrinkled her nose. âIt smells like rotten eggs.â
Garrett turned, his face dark with anger. âWhereâs Eddie?â
âI donât know. Iââ
Just then the barn door slammed shut.