âWhatever do you mean?â
âYou know perfectly well that those fish sticks didnât leap about by themselves.â
Philomena looked up and down the table at the other girls. None of them was laughing anymore. âPoor Claire overturned her plate, and her lunch flew everywhere. It was rather clumsy of her, donât you all agree?â Some of the girls nodded. âMiss Westfield, Iâm sure Miss Pimm has no time for silly stories. And what could possibly possess her to take your word over mine?â
âSheâs right, you know.â Claire wiped at her dress miserably with a handkerchief. âPlease, Hilary, donât waste your time on my account.â
âBut it wouldnât be a waste. . . .â
Claire stood up and let fish sticks fall from her skirts. âHilary,â she said quietly, âwould you be good enough to accompany me to our room? I believe Iâve lost my appetite.â
C LAIRE HURRIED UP the dormitory staircase without saying a word, and Hilary could hardly keep up with her. As soon as theyâd reached their room, Claire slammed the door behind them, threw herself onto her bed, and covered herself in blankets.
The gargoyle looked up from the pages of Treasure Island . âOh, good,â he said; âyouâre back. Is it time to go to sea?â
Under the blankets, the lump that was Claire let out a great and tragic wail.
Hilary shook her head at the gargoyle and ran to Claireâs bedside. âLet me take care of Philomena,â she said. âIf Miss Pimm only knew how horrid she was, she wouldnât stand for it.â
The lump sniffled. âIt was my fault,â it said. âI shouldnât have laughed. Oh dear!â Then the lump gave a great heave and resumed wailing.
âYou didnât do a thing wrong,â said Hilary, patting the lump where she thought Claireâs back might be. âYou defended your honor like a true pirate. But Philomenaâs got magic somehow, and sheâs even more awful with it than without it. Weâve got to do something!â
The lump writhed about as Claire attempted to untangle herself from her blankets. She sat up at last and blew her nose on the handkerchief Hilary offered her. âYou donât understand,â she said. âThereâs nothing to be done. Itâs not only Philomena who acts that wayâwho uses magic to be nasty, I mean. You should see them at the fishmongerâs. All sorts of grand High Society gentlemen come in with magic coins, enchanting extra trout into their parcels. They donât pay for them, of course.â Claire tugged at her blankets. âThey do laugh quite a bit, though.â
âBut thatâs terrible!â If a grand gentleman ever tried something of the sort on Hilary, heâd quickly find a cutlass pressed against his linen-ruffled throat. âCanât you do anything to stop them?â
Claire laughed, but she didnât sound happy. âI donât have a gargoyle to protect me, and Iâm not a pirate like you. I thought things would be better at Miss PimmâsâI thought no one would dare use magic on a High Society girl.â She pulled her bedding back over her head. âNow, if you donât mind, Iâm going to spend the rest of my life under these blankets.â
âOh, Claire, I do mind. You canât stay a lump forever. How will you go to class?â
âLumps donât need to go to class,â said Claire from under the blanket.
âWell, then, youâll need to eat.â
Claire shuddered. âIâm never eating again! What if itâs fish sticks? â
After a few minutes, she poked her head out of the blankets. âI guess I am a little hungry, though. I hardly got any lunch.â
âYou could go to the market,â Hilary said. âYouâre allowed to go into town this afternoon. And Iâm sure they wonât have fish