Prologue
Love and BFFs
W HO DIDN â T LIKE A COOKIE EXCHANGE ? Well, other than a surly teenager.
Muriel Sterling-Wittmanâs little house was filled with friends and the aroma of hot chocolate. And every inch of space on her dining room table was covered with plates of cookiesâcookies smothered in frosting, cookies oozing chocolate, cookies with gumdrops peeking out like colored gems. Scented candles added to the good smells, and the room buzzed with conversation as three generations of Icicle Falls residents swapped recipes and gossip.
In one corner Olivia Wallace was making a face over some cheeky remark her friend Dot Morrison had just made. Murielâs daughters were gathered around the punch bowl, which was full of eggnog punch, while Janice Lind, the grand old dame of Christmas baking, was holding court on Murielâs sofa with Muriel, her friend Pat Wilder and Patâs daughter Isabel keeping her company. Some of the younger girls were hovering over the table, sneaking cookies.
Normally Patâs fourteen-year-old granddaughter, Clara, would have been with them, but right now she sat in a chair with her back to the group, scowling like a miniature Scrooge in drag. This was a first. Pat had been bringing her granddaughter to Murielâs cookie exchanges ever since she was five. And sheâd always been excited to be there, happy to play with the other little girls whose mothers had deemed them worthy of the privilege of attending. Instead, here she sat, the expression on her face as dark as her hair.
âWhy donât you go hang out with the girls?â asked Pat.
âNo, thanks.â Clara shot a dagger glare over to where the other girls were gathered in a giggling clump. All except for one, who was sneaking anxious looks in Claraâs direction.
Pat and Muriel exchanged glances.
âShe and Aurora are having issues,â Isabel, her mother, explained.
Murielâs daughters Cecily and Bailey had joined them now, leaving Samantha in charge of the punch bowl. Cecily helped Murielâs oldest daughter, Samantha, run Sweet Dreams Chocolates, the familyâs chocolate company, and Bailey owned a successful tea shop in town. All three of them were happily settled with the right man now and busy with work, and Cecily was expecting a baby in February. But they always gave the cookie exchange top priority.
âI need this recipe,â Bailey announced, holding up a chocolate cookie filled with candied cherries. She smiled at the scowling Clara and said, âYou look like you need chocolate.â
Clara shrugged.
âWhatâs wrong?â Bailey asked.
âNothing,â Clara muttered.
Now one of the other girls had drifted over, a pretty girl with strawberry-blond hair and freckles, Claraâs best friend, Aurora.
Make that former best friend, judging by the way Clara turned her back. âGo away. Iâm not talking to you.â
Tears sprang to Auroraâs eyes. âPlease donât be mad, Clara. Itâs not
my
fault Garth likes me now.â
âYes, it is. You stole him. He liked me first.â
âAnd so now youâre not speaking to her,â Bailey deduced.
âShe stole him,â Clara hissed, in case theyâd missed that piece of vital information the first time.
âWeâve been down that road,â Cecily said, and put an arm around her sister. âIt was a dumb road. Especially considering how well things worked out.â
âWhat do you mean?â Aurora asked, settling onto the couch next to Muriel.
âI mean Bailey and I both wanted the same man. But in the end, we each got the person we were meant to be with.â
âWell, I was meant to be with Garth,â Clara said, her scowl deepening.â
Pat smiled. âYes, I understand those feelings. You know, I thought I was meant to be with someone once and my best friend got him.â
âWho was that?â asked Clara, forgetting