she wrote, looking to the three of us for confirmation:
1.  Great-grandfather E.S. and pirate Mary Maude Lee had a childâMarni!
We glanced at Marni. Then, as if to prove the point, Pru unrolled and smoothed the scrolled document portraying the Simmons family tree. We stared at the branches illustrating how we were all connected to one anotherâand to the curse.
Â
Â
Pru penciled the next clue:
2.  E.S. stole Mary Maude Leeâs treasure and M.M.L. placed a curse on all the Simmons men, killing three generations thus far.
âNot to mention the loss of your mother and Aunt Margaret,â Marni added. âAnd the close calls all of us have had. It seems no one related to the family is safe.â She paused for emphasis, then pointed toward the lyric sheet. Pru wrote:
3.  The ballad explains that the treasure must be returned to Mary Maude Leeâs kin for the curse to be lifted.
Pru and I exchanged a knowing look. Three of the once-famous female pirateâs relatives sat around this very tableâPru, Marni, and myself.
4.  E.S. had fled to Australia, but we didnât find the treasure there.
Walter laughed. âIâll never forget all those holes you dug out there in the outback looking for âJ-3ââonly to find it here on Clare Island.â
Pru smiled ruefully, waving one hand under our noses. âI still have the callouses to show for itâand little else!â She bit her bottom lip and went back to her list.
5.  Another group is desperate to find the treasureâQuaide, the pirate, and the green-eyed man.
Walter nodded. âTheyâve been tailing us every step of the way. The question is, are they just treasure hunters following the rumors of Edwardâs exploits? Or are they connected in some other way? What do they know that we donât?â
âGood question,â Pru said, tapping the pencil on the table before going on.
6.  The cards my grandmotherâyour great-grandmotherâMolly OâMalley designed depict the treasure being buried in a grave on Clare Island. But the treasure is gone.
âAnd,â I added, âbesides Old Peader, there was no corpse in the coffin. Either it has been removed or it was never there to begin with.â
âGood point,â Pru said.
âMaybe your great-grandfather faked his death,â Walter suggested.
âAnd buried his treasure in his own grave!â Pru scribbled furiously:
7.  Edwardâs wife, Molly, carved a message on the coffinâsuggesting sheâd stolen the treasure to double-cross him.
With that, one of the cards flipped up from its spot on the table and hovered around us. Before I even looked I knew which card it would beâthe queen of diamonds, Molly OâMalley. My great-grandmother leaned off the card, her jowly face raised defiantly, wagging her chubby index finger in the air. âNobody deceives me and gets away with it!â she crowed.
My auntâs voice rose to a shrill cry. Her cheeks were flushed and her mouth pinched. âBut Lucy and I are your own flesh and blood,â Prudence cried. âWhy donât you help us? Tell us what you know? Holding back has led to many deaths alreadyâyour own son, Edward the Second; my brother and Lucyâs father, Edward the Third; my brother, Victor; not to mention Lucyâs mother, Johanna, and Victorâs wife, Margaret! When is enough, enough? Youâre no better than Mary Maude Lee! In fact, youâre worse!â
The force of Pruâs emotion caused the animated card to quiver and dip. I almost expected it to revert to being just a plain old card again and drop, lifeless, to the table.
But it flipped up again, the queen of diamondsâs face like that of a spoiled child, her bottom lip petulantly rolled. âWhat makes you so sure I know where the treasure is?â
âYour message carved on the lid of the