Grey Man about, ye can never tell.â
I avoided his eyes and quickened my step. I felt his hand on my arm.
âPardon me, Lucy. Have I gone ânâ upset ye? Jest worried for ye, is all.â
âIt will be all right,â I said, and realized that I meant it.
Grady and Seamus agreed to take Old Peader back to his home, to put it back in order after the ransacking and tuck the old fellow into bed, his loyal Rosie following behind. Heâd been through way too much for one day. Pru, Walter, Pugsley, and I took the turnoff to our cottage.
The snug little house was dark and closed up tightâeven from a distance it was obvious no one was there. âI knew it didnât seem possible,â Pru murmured, âthat Marni would be hereâbut all the same I have this strong feeling that sheâs safe.â
Inside we poked at the fire and lit the lanterns, all without a word. Pru watched me carefully, more kindly than Grady had, and I knew she could sense I was withholding something. My loyalty torn, I avoided her eyes.
âI . . . may have seen something out there,â I began.
I could feel Pruâs interest flare like one of the peat bricks in the fireplace. âWhere?â she asked. âWhat do you think you saw?â
âIn the water. It could have been a fishâa porpoise. Or maybe a seal.â I hesitated. âBut it might have been Marni.â
âMarni does not look like a porpoise,â Pru began.
âSwimming. What I saw was definitely swimming.â
âWhy didnât you say anything?â Walter asked.
âBecause I didnât want Grady and Seamus to know.â I knew they both understood.
The door suddenly swung open. There was Marni, slick as a seal. Our eyes met. âAre you going to get me a towel, so I donât drip all over the floor?â
In an instant Walter had a blanket wrapped around her. âGet out of those wet clothes,â Pru insisted. Marni went into our room and quietly closed the door behind her.
In relief we exhaled. There would be no more questions tonight. As Pru and I settled into bed, we both took in Marniâs slim form beneath the blankets, the gentle rise and fall of her shoulders. What a night it had beenâweâd unearthed a grave, found an old man buried alive, and had almost been drawn into the sea by the Grey Manâor the curse. Perhaps Marni actually had been. But a part of me knew she hadnât been lured at all. Sheâd jumped into the sea, and swam as close as she could to whatever it was sheâd needed to see. I only hoped sheâd tell us what that was.
Though exhausted I knew I wouldnât soon fall asleep. And the same nervous energy that buzzed in my head was flowing from Aunt Prudence as well. It moved like a current between us, and the atmosphere in the room felt like the air before a thunderstorm. Tingling. Electric. Unsettled, with the potential for danger.
âTomorrow,â Pru whispered, âwe need to look at everything we know. Put the pieces together. Make a plan.â
âYes,â I murmured. I didnât voice the thought that crept up behind those words . . . Before itâs too late.
10
F our of us sat at the table and spread the deck of cards before us. Side by side we laid out our clues. âWe have to be missing something,â Pru said. âSomething so obvious weâre not seeing it.â
I hunched over the display, searching for some scrap of significance we may have overlooked. Walter frowned in concentration. Marni, however, seemed distracted, distant. She went through the motions of considering this and that, but her mind was elsewhere. I gazed at her, undetected, and wondered what was going on behind those sea-green eyes of hers. A mystery, as always.
Pru tore several pieces of paper from her notebook. âLetâs review what we know.â She licked the tip of the pencil, reading each word aloud as