aboutâ¦â Judith frowned, and my suspicion stirred.
âYou think she was that vague deliberately? Why?â
âIâm not sure. She might have reverted to old habits under stress. Orâ¦â
âOr?â
âShe may have thought you wouldnât be willing to come just to help Max.â
I snorted. âJust to help Max I wouldnât, but my familyâs fate is pretty well tied to his. What happened?â
Judithâs eyes were distant. âIt really started with the fireâ¦.â
It took the rest of the afternoon to get the whole story. It seemed old Max, along with most of the merchants in the city, was heavily invested in a convoy ofships that was setting off to trade in Tallowsport. The ships hadnât even left the dock when a fire started in one of the shipyards, burning a shed full of pitch kegs, which then exploded.
âThe fire went everywhere, Fisk. Dozens of people were burned and three men died!â
Eight ships had burned to the waterline, among them the ships Maxwell had invested in.
âSo we lost a lot of money, but Max hadnât borrowedâit was just his savings.â Weâd finished the silver by this time and were spreading the heavy linen tablecloth. It, too, Judith said, was to be sold after tonight. âI donât suppose youâve acquired a fortune over the last five years?â
âNo, but at least I didnât lose one. Go on.â
The real disaster occurred almost a month after the fire. Maxwell had judged a murder, an ugly case where two drunken tanners had raped and killed a traveling player whoâd beaten them at a shell game. It was horrible, but it seemed clear-cut. There were two witnesses; one of them, a woman too ill to rise and go for help, actually saw the crime committed. The other had seen the two men enter the alley where the girl was killed. Both of them identified the tanners, whom Maxwell, quite properly, ordered hanged.
Then, over a month after the trial, the invalid killedherself, leaving a note that she could no longer bear the guilt of lying two men to their death, and that sheâd been bribed to identify themâ¦by Judicar Maxwell. The Judicary Guild ordered an immediate investigation. They had complete confidence in Maxâs honestyâthough that wavered a bit when they discovered that the other witness had left town a month before the womanâs death. The guild audited Maxwellâs books and bank account and found nothing suspicious until some bright young clerk had the notion to search Maxâs study. In a hidden compartment beneath a window seat they found another set of ledgers, for a bank account in Fallon. They were in Maxwellâs handwriting and showed heâd received a large sum of money not long before the hearing, and paid out several smaller sums of money, one of which exactly matched the amount the womanâs suicide note claimed sheâd been paid.
When Judith told me the sum that was left, I whistled. âIt sounds like old Max recouped his losses.â
Judithâs eyes flashed. âIf youâd been here, you wouldnât joke about it.â
I wasnât joking. At least, not entirely. But Judith went on, âHe lost everything he cares about except his family. Not just money, but the respect of the community, his position. Hisâ¦place. He was framed, Fisk.And they did a cursed good job, too.â Her expression was grim.
âJudith, are you sure of that? Anyone can beââ
âNot Max. Iâve lived in his house for five years. Iâm certain. He was framed.â
If Anna had said that, I wouldnât have paid much attention, but Judith had sat through the same lessons I hadâa scholar was trained to evaluate the facts. And Judith was Judith. Putting compassion above truth wasnât one of her virtues, but if Max had been framedâ¦
âBy who then? And why?â
âThat, dear brother, is the