fooling around.â
Dennis explained the need to formalize the business contract before having any further discussion, explaining, âSigning the contract establishes attorney-client privilege.â They reviewed it together and Lauren hired Dennis by signing on the dotted line.
âI can begin making some phone calls on your behalf now that I officially represent you. Iâve practiced in this city my entire career. I even used to be one of those SOB prosecutors once upon a time.â Dennis chuckled. âIâm well-acquainted with most of the judges in this town and a great many of the prosecutors. Iâll start making calls today and find out why the police find you so interesting. I donât think itâs because youâre easy on the eyes, though that will help if we have to go in front of a jury.â
Lauren usually felt uncomfortable when a man complimented her, but she knew Dennis was not hitting on her. He was simply sizing up her potential strengths and weaknesses in front of a jury. She imagined this came naturally to him, just as she was inclined to notice any obvious signs of disease in people.
âNow, Lauren. I never ask my clients if they are guiltyâ¦â
âIâm not guilââ she started to say before he shushed her.
âAs I was saying, I never ask my clients if they are guilty or not and there are some fine reasons for that. First of all, itâs completely irrelevant. That might sound strange to you. Most people think criminal prosecutions are about determining whether the accused is guilty or not guilty, but that isnât true. Trials are about determining whether the prosecution can prove the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt,and thatâs a different question altogether. Second, Iâm in a better position to defend my clients when I operate on a presumption of innocence.â
Thatâs probably because most of your clients are guilty, Lauren thought.
âFinally, it is my legal obligation to ensure you do not perjure yourself. If you are charged with this crime, it is your constitutional right to refuse to testify. However, if you did choose to testify on your own behalf, I could not allow you to testify to anything I know to be untrue. You see what I mean?â
Lauren nodded. His rhetoric was stoking her fear as she imagined being charged with Lizâs murder.
âFor this reason, you and I will often speak in hypotheticals. When I start a question with the phrase âhypothetically speaking,â Iâm not asking you to tell me about something that happened in your own life, Iâm just asking you to explore the facts of the case as you know them in a hypothetical manner. You see what I mean?â
âYes.â Lauren was familiar with this strategy. Doctors used similar tactics to discuss cases with the hospital legal office.
âI take my job very seriously. Every citizen in this country is entitled to a rigorous defense and that is what I pledge to provide for you. You wonât find any other lawyer in this state who would defend you as relentlessly as I will. Andâ¦â he paused for emphasis, ââ¦I never violate attorney-client privilege, not even to my own wife. I say that because it is imperative you feel comfortable confiding in me. Do you have any questions whatsoever about that?â
âYes,â Lauren responded, thinking about doctor-patient confidentiality. Most of the things patients told Lauren were legally protected from disclosure, but there were some exceptions such as threats of self-harm or issues affecting public safety. âAre there any exceptions to attorney-client privilege?â
âNone. Zilch, zero, nada. Not even your death would vacate the privilege. Not disclosures of past crimes. There are absolutely no exceptions whatsoever save the one I mentioned already. I cannot knowingly allow you to commit perjury or any other future crime. Anymore