p.m. Wednesday.
Seneca Village Police Chief Ron Webster commented, âEvery year we warn kids to be careful in that glen, and every year we end up rescuing someone. I sure hate to see a thing like this happen.â
He added that âthere is no reason to believe this was anything but an accident.â Near where Lucyâs sweatshirt was left, police found what appeared to be evidence of Lucyâs slide off the cliff edge. âWe couldnât see clear footprints because of the rain that fell Wednesday night, but there was a long mud slick heading right off the edge of the cliff. I figure thatâs where she lost her footing,â he said.
The search will continue in Seneca Lake. Chief Webster stated grimly, âExcept, now, I guess itâs a search for the body.â
Allie was totally absorbed, reaching for one newspaper after another. The articles became smaller and smaller and less and less hopeful. After five days, the search was abandoned. There was no mention of Lucy Stiles for a week. Then Allie came to an article with the headline: MISSING GIRL BELIEVED DEAD; FUNERAL SERVICES TO BE HELD .
She read that local, county, and state officials had completed their investigation into the death of Lucy Stiles, ultimately declaring it âa tragic and fatal accident.â
Lucyâs mother, Rebecca Stiles, reluctantly accepted the verdict that Lucy had not survived. Funeral services were to be held at the Presbyterian Church, followed by a burial in Fossil Glen Cemetery.
With amazement she read:
âSeneca Heights School officials were unanimous in their praise for Lucy and their sorrow over her death. Mr. Justin Henry, Lucyâs sixth-grade teacher, said, âThis has been a nightmare for our whole class. We all loved Lucy, and hoped so much that sheâd be back. We will miss her terribly.â
Allie looked up, feeling dazed. She caught Dubâs eye and motioned for him to come over.
âLook at this,â she whispered.
Dubâs eyes grew wider as they traveled down the columns of newsprint in one paper after another. When he finished, he let out a low whistle. âWow. I donât remember hearing anything about this.â
âIt was four years ago,â said Allie. âWe were dumb little kids; we didnât know anything.â
âI canât believe she had Mr. Henry for a teacher!â
âLetâs ask him about it,â said Allie. She raised her hand and Mr. Henry came over. Pointing to the newspaper article, she said, âLucy Stiles was in your class?â
Mr. Henry nodded, and a shadow darkened his usually sunny face. âThat was a terrible time,â he said. âSometimes I still canât believe sheâs dead. Lucy was great; smart and imaginative.â He smiled at Allie. âYou remind me of her, as a matter of fact.â
Allie blushed at the unexpected compliment.
He went on. âI had just begun teaching, so Lucy was one of my very first students. When they said she was dead, Iââ He stopped for a moment, swallowed, and shook his head. âIt was so sad and senseless, the way it happened. She knew that glen like the back of her hand. She wasnât a careless, reckless kid. Thatâs why I kept hoping it was all a mistake. But after a while there was no point in pretending she was still alive.â
Allie and Dub were quiet as Mr. Henry stood by their table, a faraway look on his face. Then Allie asked, âWas she the only kid in the Stiles family?â
âYes,â answered Mr. Henry. âAnd her father had died a few years before that, so Mrs. Stiles was left all alone.â
âWhere did she go?â asked Allie.
âTo California, I think,â said Mr. Henry. âShe had family there. I imagine this town was full of painful memories for her.â
âYeah,â agreed Allie and Dub solemnly.
âThe house just sits there getting more rickety and