head. âNot really. I mean, I was mostly looking at the silver. I saw her out of the corner of my eye so to speak, but I couldnât swear that she didnât put anything in it.â
âNo, naturally not,â said Carmichael, although he knew that in fact no poison had been found in the pot, only in the cup. Since they now knew the poison had come from the vase in the study, that went far in ruling Kitty Whitcomb out. She could only have poisoned Berowne if she had reentered the study after seeing Annette leave the house.
âWhat Iâm interested in,â continued Carmichael, âis how long Miss Whitcomb was gone. You told Commander Andrews it was less than five minutes.â
âThatâs right,â said Fatima, nodding seriously. âI didnât actually
notice the time when she went up, but it must have been eleven because thatâs when Mr. Berowne always had his coffee. And when she came back, Kitty said we deserved some elevenses, too, and we both sat down with a cuppa. I looked at the clock then, so Iâd know how long a break I took, and it was just five minutes past.â
âAnd Miss Whitcomb never left the kitchen again, until she went up to fetch the tray?â
âShe didnât, sir. Sheâd have had to walk right past me, and I couldnât have helped but notice.â
âThatâs very good, Miss Sathay,â said Carmichael, smiling. âNow Iâd just like to have your impressions of the household. Did everyone seem to get on together?â
âWell, I suppose so,â she answered. âI didnât really see very much of them, except for Mrs. Simmons and Kitty. Sometimes Iâd overhear people talking while I was cleaning, but I never heard any fights. Miss Wellman was a bit sharp with everyone and I donât think she liked Mrs. Berowne much, but I never heard them arguing.â
âHow about Mr. and Mrs. Berowne?â
âThey seemed very fond of each other, sir, for all heâs so much older than her. But she didnât seem to mind that. I heard them once,â she added, lowering her voice, âwhen I was in the hall outside their bedroom. It was right in the middle of the afternoon!â
âIs that so?â Carmichael hid a smile at her indignation. Clearly in her seventeen-year-old mind older married people should reserve sex for the nighttime hours. He thanked her and took his leave.
âThat pretty well knocks Kitty Whitcomb out of it, donât you think?â asked Gibbons outside.
âAlmost certainly,â Carmichael agreed. âItâs still barely possible that she went back into the study and contrived to pour Berowne a cup of coffee, but I canât see how she would have managed it in the time. She couldnât just march in, pour the coffee, and leave; sheâd have to at least speak to him briefly.â He sighed. âBut of course, Surrey
CID never really suspected any of the servants. Andrews and Gorringe are convinced itâs one of the family.â
Â
Â
Gibbons loosened his tie and took a long, grateful draught of single malt scotch, savouring the smoky aroma the Isle of Isla is so deservedly famous for. He relaxed with a sigh into an overstuffed armchair, propping his feet on one of the five coffee tables in Bethancourtâs drawing room. Bethancourt was a wealthy young man, but with eccentric tastes. He was very fond of coffee tables.
The room itself was spacious, with the graceful proportions of a bygone era. The wide windows with their elegant moldings were hung with heavy gold drapes, only a shade different from the gold Aubusson carpet. Both these items had been chosen by Bethancourtâs mother, a woman with excellent taste. Bethancourt himself had supplied the rest of the furnishings, which were also excellent individually, but which hardly created a cohesive whole. The five coffee tables were all of differing styles, while the Chesterfield
Tracie Peterson, Judith Miller