Iâm not sure what else to say. Heâll be sorely missed.â
âWeâve been told that he was deeply religious,â said Carmichael.
âOh, yes.â Oakley nodded agreement. âFaith had taken a strong hold of him in his youthâhe apparently considered becoming a minister, or so he once told me, but of course his father expected him to take over the family business.â
âWould he have made a good minister in your opinion?â
Oakley hesitated, his eyes narrowed in thought. âNo,â he answered at last. âAs I said, he was not a sensitive man and I believe a certain amount of sensitivity is necessary in my job. He had very strong views on right and wrong and was not apt to be very sympathetic
to transgressors. He could be rather intolerant. But I feel I am giving you a wrong impression of him. He was, I think, a happy man for the most part, and he was certainly successful. People in his position donât often become introspective and thereâs no reason why they should.â
âWeâve also been told he had a temper,â prompted Carmichael.
âA temper?â Oakley smiled. âMore a bit of bluster when anything upset him, I should say. He always calmed down quickly, though he wasnât good at admitting he was in the wrong even when that was true. But then, I donât know many people who are.â
âNo,â agreed Carmichael. âChagrin and atonement donât usually go hand in hand. Had he been worried lately, do you know?â
âNothing that he mentioned to me,â answered Oakley. He paused and then added, âHe did say sometime back that he was concerned over Paulâs handling of the company, but that was several months ago. He was planning a lengthy vacation with Mrs. Berowne at the time, and was worried how Paul would do without him.â
âBut he took the vacation anyway?â
âYes. I certainly recommended that he do so, and I believe Mrs. Berowne was quite eager for the trip. He liked to please her.â
âYou seem a shrewd judge of character, Reverend,â said Carmichael. âWhat do you think of Mrs. Berowne?â
Oakley smiled. âIâve heard the rumours, of course,â he replied. âMy own wife thinks Annette killed Geoffrey. But I canât say I agree. I thought Annette was very fond of her husband and she certainly seemed grief-stricken after his death. Annette has always struck me as being just a little unsure of herself and I think being Geoffreyâs wife compensated for that.â
âUnsure?â Carmichael raised an eyebrow. âI donât think I would have described her that way, Reverend.â
âOh, not outwardly,â replied Oakley. âAll Iâm saying is that I think her outward self-confidence stemmed from being Mrs. Geoffrey Berowne.â
âBut sheâs still Mrs. Geoffrey Berowne,â said Carmichael.
âWell, yes. But itâs not the same.â
âNo,â agreed Carmichael. âNot the same at all.â
Â
Â
Fatima Sathay had gotten a job as a receptionist in a local hair salon. She was a doe-eyed Indian girl with a shy smile, very earnest, but nonetheless rather enjoying her role as chief witness. Carmichael was relieved to be interviewing her at work and not in the presence of her parents, whom Commander Andrews had described as âguardian dragons.â
âI got to the house at nine that morning,â she said, âand went up and made the beds just like always. Then I helped Kitty clear away the breakfast things since Mrs. Simmons was over at Little House. Sheâd asked me to do the silver, so I brought it all down to the kitchen and got started, thinking Iâd do the dusting later.â
âAnd you were still there when Miss Whitcomb took up the coffee tray?â asked Carmichael.
âYes, sir.â
âDid you see her make it up?â
Fatima shook her