time for things like this: band shows, impromptu trips to Europe. Or who knows, maybe even as a graduation present. Cat . . . I think you just . . . you have to see the bigger picture here.â
I can hear the no between every word and itâs tearing me apart. âMom, my twenties are forever from now! And besides, this is the bigger picture. This is a once-in-a-lifetime chance to do something amazing, and itâs right there for the taking. Let me go to London and Iâll go to Stanford like a good girlââ Where are these words coming from? Desperate. Am I even serious? Or just spinning more liesâ âAnd I wonât even fuss about it.â
âSee? That kind of talk, right there,â says Dad, his voice rising. âItâs not being a good little girl to go to college. It seems like ever since you started dating this boy, youâThis just isnât the Cat we know.â
âThatâs my point!â I say. âMaybe Iâm not the little Cat you think you know. But that doesnât have anything to do with Caleb. Itâs what Iâm trying to tell youââ
But Dad isnât hearing me. âHow can you expect us to believe you after last week? How can we trust you? If we let you do this, youâre just more likely to . . .â He throws up his hands. âYouâll want to go on tour all summer, miss college, or worse, start college and drop out and ruin your futurechances. Where is it going to end?â
âDad, thatâs not how itâs going to be!â
But Dad shakes his head like heâs made up his mind. âI think youâre in over your head here, Cat. This world of music and musicians is clearly messing with your thinking in some unhelpful ways. I mean, we are talking about tapes left by a drug addict who killed himself and abandoned his family! He is no hero.â
It takes all my will not to respond. I bite my lip hard as the tears come.
âI know you love working with this band,â says Dad, âbut . . . youâre not even in the band.â
âWow,â I mutter.
âThatâs notââ says Dad. âWhat I mean is youâre a girl on a trajectory , a high achiever, college-bound, and Iâm sorry but weâre just not going to let this band preoccupation derail your potential. It has to stop.â
âDad, itâs not a preoccupation ,â I say, my voice tight, trying not to sob. âItâs a passion!â
âThen maybe you need to find another passion!â Dad balls his fist and I see him shake off a surge of anger. âIâm sorry, Cat, but, man! You have academics. You had volleyball . . . Weâve stood by and let you shun so many other possibilities in school, things like student government . . . Honestly youâre lucky, damn lucky, to still be getting considered for a school like Stanford with all the time you waste on these bands! It is a privilege to have what you have, and to listen to you takeit for granted, and to ask for these silly things is . . . Iâve had enough! Taking that phone call from Andre, having to fly you home, watching you slouch around that scummy practice space . . . itâs not you, Catherine! Itâs not you.â
Iâm crying now. Full-on.
But Iâm not going to yell anymore.
The cards are finally on the table.
âIt is me,â I say quietly.
My tears have the predictable effect of bringing Dad down a notch. I sort of hate that, the power of my weakness. No cheat codes. But I canât help crying.
âLook, Iâm sorry to get so angry . . .â But he doesnât finish.
Mom sighs. âI agree with your father. I know it may be hard to understand where weâre coming fromââ
âNo,â I say, still crying, but firm. âNo, I get it. I totally get it.â
We stand there silent. Mom rearranges the pie plates, but doesnât ask us if we want any. There will be no
Richard Belzer, David Wayne
Tim Lahaye, Jerry B. Jenkins