with.â
âIâve told you,â Loveridge said, âthis is unnecessary . The darned thing wasnât insured, but if itâs gone, itâs gone . I donât want to lose all my friends as a consequence.â
âYou wonât lose â em if you let them clear themselves,â French said. â Nora Mayhew was right. Theyâll be much happier to turn out their pockets and have it all above board.â
âSpeak for yourself,â said Peter.
We all looked at him in surprise.
âWhat dâyou mean?â
âI think Bobâs right about this,â Peter said. âHe invited us here as his friends. Something has vanished. Disappeared down a hole, maybe. Thatâs bad luck for everybody. But if we have to turn out our pockets just to prove that we havenât stolen the thing, then for Godâs sake â¦â
âExactly ââ Bob said.
âNot exactly at all,â French said. âNora Mayhew was right. Itâs plain common sense ââ
âFor Heavenâs sake stop sheltering behind Nora Mayhew,â Peter snapped. âIf itâs your opinion, say so!â
French was still as cool as heâd been at poker. âAll right, itâs my opinion, then. If I go now, without any check, and the ear-ringâs never found, then I could never come here again. Bob may be a trustful sort of chap, but he canât help his thoughts.â
Peter Stevenson looked at me, but, much as I disliked French, I really had to agree with him over this. If you got a clearance now, well, then you were in the clear. Of course, they were both right in a sense. How can you choose between trust and proof?
Peter put down the magazine. â It so happens that I donât want to turn out my pockets. Right? The reasonâs unimportant. I just donât. Youâve known me for about nine months, Bob. You, Lucille, for about twelve. Well, I give you my word that Iâve never touched your ear-ring tonight. Will that be enough? Satisfactory? Or is it not enough?â
âOf course ââ
âOf course,â Bob said slowly. âI donât want to ââ
âWell thanks,â said French. âBut I suppose you realize that it leaves us in a position of thinking anything we choose.â
He turned to the card table, which by now had been cleared of everything else and methodically emptied all his pockets. Having done that, he pulled his jacket inside out the way George Mayhew had done and then went towards Bob Loveridge in his shirt sleeves with his hands in the air.
Bob said: âNo, no,â so French then tamed to me, and to satisfy him I patted his trousers and under his arms. Then, because I certainly didnât want to be saddled with any of the blame, I did the same. God knows, there wasnât much in my pockets but an empty wallet, a handkerchief and a bunch of keys. When it was done and we had our coats on again French looked at Peter. I thought Peter was being an obstinate fool too and said, much to my later regret: â Come on, itâs nothing; get it over. Bob doesnât want it, but we ought to insist on it as a matter of common good manners. Then the whole thing can be dropped. Like the ear-ring. I think the bloody thingâs still stuck in the springs of one of the arm-chairs.â
Peter looked at me, and the way he looked gave me the first qualm. Until then I had only been anxious to clear him of any suspicion of bad temper, nothing more.
He abruptly jerked round and looked at Lucille, then he turned to Bob Loveridge.
â Well , if you will have it you will have it! The reason I didnât want to empty my pockets is that I have an ear-ring I brought to show you thatâs just like the one thatâs disappeared.â
We looked back at him, feeling pretty stupid ourselves, while he put his hand in his pocket and fumbled about and then took out a Swan Vestas matchbox. He put