looked the other way. Lace-curtain Irish. We had to be perfect little ladies. Jean couldnât stand that. She went through some rough patches.â
I sipped tea, and she talked about her dead sister.
âJean was a good girl. She really was. But she always felt she was a disappointment to everyone, making one mistake after another, never living up to her potential.â
âThat must have been difficult.â
âIt was. For me, too. She used to see everything I accomplished as an attack on her, as part of some grand plan to humiliate her. But it wasnât like that. Not at all. I loved my sister dearly.â
âI can see that.â
âJoe changed everything. He worked some kind of magic on her. He made her feel special. And she became special. She truly did. She turned herself around. We didnât understand at first, how it all happened. It was right after his mother died that they got serious. Maybe he was vulnerable, maybe he saw something in her the rest of us didnât. Oh, she was pretty, Jean was, and smart as can be. But unpolished, not the kind everybody thought heâd wind up with.â
âFrom what I understand, Joe wasnât exactly born with a silver spoon in his mouth.â
âTrue. But he was on his way up, and everyone knew it. Jean knew it, too. She was sure they could make something of their lives, if only they stuck together. She wanted to be someone, you see. To show everyone. But it was all for nothing,â Mrs. Flynn said, her smile dissolving.
âDidnât you ever question his guilt?â I asked, hoping sheâd throw me a crumb.
She looked away, as if to even acknowledge the question would be a betrayal.
Finally, she said in a low voice, âI did, at first. I didnât want to believe it. It hardly seemed possible that such a thing could happen, that this boy we all admired so much could be responsible for something so awful.â She grabbed hold of the arm of the sofa, as if she needed to steady herself.I should have stopped her from going on, but I had to know.
âI went to see him in jail that first night, Miss Caruso,â she said, her eyes looking into mine now. âHe was devastated. It was as if his soul had up and left his body. I was frightenedâhe wasnât moving, wasnât speaking. I worried about him, I did, but the evidence just seemed to mount.â Her voice rose. âAnd who else could have done it? Tell me. Who could have wanted to harm her? It was the only explanation. The police insisted. Itâs always the husband.â
I wasnât about to convince her that there were dozens of other scenarios that could have played out that night. This was the story sheâd chosen to believe. I was ready to give up when she caught me off guard.
âThen I found the scrap of paper. It changed everything. Any doubts I may have harbored about Joeâs guilt were gone forever.â
Mrs. Flynn was a refined woman, but not one to equivocate. She walked over to the roll-top desk, opened the bottom drawer, and took out a very small, very yellowed piece of paper. It was crumbling at the edges.
âRead what it says.â
ââMeredith Allan. MI6-7979.ââ I looked up. âIâm afraid I donât understand.â
She sighed. âMaddy Seaton, Jeanâs best friend, told me Jean suspected Joe of having an affair. The police as much as guessed that anyway. Thatâs usually how it goes. But they couldnât find any proof. That was only because they didnât look hard enough. I found that scrap of paper stuck to the bottom drawer of Jeanâs desk a few years ago, when I was cleaning it out. The police mustâve missed it all those yearsago when they searched the house after sheâd been killed. I had to peel it off the wood. Itâs Joeâs handwriting, you see. And Meredith Allan was the richest, most beautiful girl in town. Joe fell in love with