the story was that they were happy. Because what if she fixed it all up and things really were good again? She didnât want Mom and the girls to harbor bad feelings about Hal, about how heâd made things tough for her.â
The two inspectors shared a look. âSo what was the problem?â Abby asked.
After a slight hesitation, Daniel came out with it. âHave you guys heard anything about Patti Orosco?â
JaMorris answered, âNo. Who is she?â
âShe was Katieâs best friend until a couple of years ago, when she started hitting on Hal.â
âAnd?â Abby asked.
âAs I understand it,â Daniel said, âtheyâre now an item. I mean, I donât know for sure, but I think itâs pretty damn likely. He still sees her all the time. Katie knew that. Heâd stop by her place coming home from work. Heâd disappear for a while on the weekends. Katie could smell her perfume on him, but she never got solid proof. Maybe she didnât want it, I donât know. I told her she ought to hire a private eye, follow the son of a bitch around, that Iâd even pay for it, but she didnât want to do it. Still, every time she talked to me, she brought it up.â
âShe didnât call him on it?â JaMorris asked.
âNo.â
Abby wanted to know, âWhy not?â
âSame thing as with my family,â he said. âIf she didnât tell them something was wrong, then when things got better, she would have saved everybody a lot of pain, and everything could go back to normal.â He ran a finger under an eye, clearly fighting his emotions. âShe was just such a stupid believer that if you ignored certain things, even important things, theyâd eventually go away. You didnât need to have a confrontation about everything.â
âGood luck with that,â JaMorris said.
âTell me about it.â Daniel scratched at a speck on the arm of his chair. Then, with apparent reluctance, he went on. âBesides, she felt she couldnât accuse him without coming straight with him herself.â
The inspectors waited.
Daniel brought his hands together on the desk. âShe had a thing with a guy a few months after Ellen was born. She was going through severe postpartum depression and made a mistake. At least thatâs how she made it sound to me. But she decided she was going to end it and not mention it to Hal, and sure enough, it all worked out. So now, if he was screwing around, it wasnât like she couldnât understand what he might be going through. If she didnât bring it up, maybe it would all go away, like hers did. Except, in this case, he wanted to get free, and he killed her.â
âOver this Patti woman?â Abby asked. âWhy would he kill her? Why not just get a divorce?â
âLet me tell you about Katie. She wants to come across as the perfect girl, the perfect woman. But if ever Hal tried to divorce her, I promise you, she would show fangs like you wouldnât believe. Sheâd go after him with everything she had, not only for betraying her but for exposing that she was the kind of person who would get betrayed. Sheâd ruin his life and any chance that he could be happy with somebody else. If I know this about Katie, and Iâm just her brother, I guarantee you Hal understood it perfectly.â
âOkay, she might want to get nasty,â JaMorris said, âbut what could she actually do?â
Suddenly, Daniel seemed to pull himself up short. Yanking at his tie, he undid the top button on his shirt and ran a finger around the inside of his collar. Letting out a heavy breath, he assayed a fragile smile. âOkay,â he said. âIâve thought a lot about how much I wanted to tell you, but here it is.â
âWhatever you want to tell us,â Abby said. âYou think she would have been able to make Halâs life